Be consistent please wrote:
Does anyone really want to place asterisks on every single performance by the shoe in the last 4 years just because shoe technology has improved? Or is it just talk?
Why are track fans so against technological improvement? If they were consistent, they'd also be opposed to the new scientific training research in the last 20 years, or the gradual shoe improvements in the last 40 years.
Either be fine with technological and scientific improvements in Athletics or be consistent and advocate for barefoot running without and physiotherapy, or coaching/nutritional books
I can see the arguments on both sides, but I personally would like to see them banned from competition. I admittedly can't provide a detailed argument against them -- there's no clear indication as to where we should draw the line in terms of technology. But after getting my first pair and taking them for a run, all I could think was "I can't believe these are allowed."
Unlike training research and access to information -- both of which still require effort and smarts to use effectively -- these shoes are an instant $250 boost for race times. All other shoes from the past few decades are at least in the same ballpark in terms of effectiveness. These are on a different level.
Why is that type of technological improvement a bad thing? For one, it does muddle history. Race times in the marathon and half marathon -- which used to be the great equalizer in terms of evaluating talent -- are no longer a reliable tool for evaluating accomplishments.
The shoes also create further divides between runners across different levels. Nike-sponsored runners can now train in these shoes full-time, which creates a massive advantage over all other professional runners. Perhaps more effective than the "spring" mechanism of the shoes is the shock-absorbing ability the shoes have for long runs. I ran a marathon in them a few weeks ago, and my lower limbs were barely sore the next day. Imagine having that day-to-day recovery all the time.
And on a lower level, club runners with the biggest bank accounts will have an advantage thanks to finances, which I hate. The more pairs of these shoes you can afford, the more you'll get that same day-to-day recovery.