Ivy alum wrote:
Very few people who have posted on this thread so far know what they are talking about. Each coach gets a few kids who will have very good chances in admission (these kids would probably need above 3.3 and 1800). 4:17 would most likely get you on this list, if you ran it in the outdoor junior season. The threshold for most ivy coaches is 9:20, 1:55-1:54, and 4:17-4:18
Well, I also ran in the Ivy League and was simply trying to give the OP a realistic assessment. His question was prefaced on the assumption that he might be 'one of their top recruits.'
According to Milesplit, there were 115 juniors last year in the USA who ran 4:17 or faster for the 1600. So, while 4:17 is certainly a very good time and most of these guys will not apply to Ivys, it is not a blow your socks off sort of time that is going to make a coach say 'I want this guy no matter what.'
In addition, some of the colleges look overseas for talent - to give an example, Harvard has brought on a couple of very fast British distance guys in the past few years, and another of their distance guys is Canadian.
My point was that it is certainly a very good time, but unless the OP has some similar times in other events - either 800 for mid - d or 3200 and cross for distance, the 4:17 might not buy him 'top recruit' status. His academics are not stellar and there are a lot of very very good distance runners out there who are also very very good students. Some of my distance teammates were 4.0+ and very close to perfect SAT or ACT.
The coaches are also recruiting sprinters, throwers, etc. and they use some of their priority slots for those guys.
While the OP may very well get into most or at least some Ivys with these numbers, he might be wise to also apply to a few other schools. Just my advice, for what it is worth, which is probably not much.
And I agree with the last poster - things change year to year depending on teams' needs.
The OP should certainly apply. My experience was that no coach would give assurance of admission during the recruiting process, but they would give an idea of what grades and test scores they thought you might need to have a good shot at it.