Asics Gel-Nimbus, Wave Rider 15, or the Nike Free 3.0

Running Shoes/Running Gear Shoes

11 years ago 05/27/2012 8:19am EDT

I'm coming back from an Achilles injury and need a new shoe. I wear orthotics and have always trained in the Nike Structure (stability), but am looking for new ideas.

It was suggested that a soft heel counter would help my Achilles (Frees), but I'm worried that the minimalism will be a stressor by forcing the calf/achilles to work harder.

Others say go for a neutral shoe ( Gel-Nimbus 14 and Wave Rider 15) but I'm not sure about the heel counter on those. The Gel-Nimbus 14 has a special Heel cushioning system that is intriguing but don't know enough about it.

Thoughts?

11 years ago 05/27/2012 8:31am EDT

re: wal-mart

Wave Rider is a firmer shoe- nimbus might be to your liking if you were in the structure previously. It has a fair amount of cushion like the structure, but without the stability posting of the structure.

Orthotics in a neutral shoe is often enough stability on its own so I wouldn't be that concerned about switching away from mid-stability.

The Nike Free isn't supposed to be an everyday shoe and I certainly wouldn't recommend it to someone who is already struggling with achilles issues.

11 years ago 05/27/2012 8:34am EDT

re: wal-mart

I know a lot of people who use the Free as an everyday trainer. It really isn't crazy minimalist or anything.

11 years ago 05/27/2012 8:37am EDT

re: abba zabba

Thanks, one vote for the Nimbus.

So the Wave Rider being a firmer shoe, does that include the heel counter? My problem is insertional, the reason I'm asking.

I'm curious though why so many people claim that the Free's helped their achilles. It seems counter-intutitve to me, so where is that coming from?

11 years ago 05/27/2012 10:02am EDT

re: wal-mart

this is the issue with the runner community from the point of a view from someone who has been working in the specailty shoe store for the past 5 years.

All runners think because it will work for them that it will work for everyone else.

My advice, go talk to your local speciality running store and get properly fitted for running shoes. Not one person on here will be able to tell you excatly what you need.

Your talking about a high end cushioning shoe, a firmed cushioning shoe and then a flexibile shoe in the free run.

11 years ago 05/27/2012 2:07pm EDT

re: The problem with runners

That's fine but let's speak generally in terms of shoe design and biomechanics. Does the Nike Free compromise the Achilles or can it actually prevent that sort of injury?

11 years ago 05/27/2012 2:42pm EDT

re: wal-mart

OK, in general terms ... the Free will help some runners and cause problems for others.

No one here can see your feet. No one here can see what your running form is like. No one here can see the wear pattern on your old shoes. Go to a good running store.

If pressure on the achilles is the problem, once you have found the best fitting shoe at your local specialty store, don't be afraid to cut it up a bit in the back to take away any pressure points. I did this to help get over retro-calcaneal bursitis and it MAY help you to.

Reply Replying to

Username

Password

Leave the password field blank to post anonymously.

Post Preview

By posting you acknowledge that you have read and abide by our Terms and Conditions.

Remember me on this device.

Asics Gel-Nimbus, Wave Rider 15, or the Nike Free 3.0

Of General Interest

This thread has already been deleted.

You have been subscribed.

Asics Gel-Nimbus, Wave Rider 15, or the Nike Free 3.0

Follow Freelove

Block Freelove

Of General Interest

This thread has already been deleted.

Reply Replying to

You have been subscribed.