I read RWTB a few months ago so I don't exactly remember Goucher's finishing places, but McDougal's NCAA finishes-4, 13, 27, X-seem to be very similar to those of Goucher's-I remember something very similar, of course winning it all his senior year. That's good enough reason for me to pick McDougal.
goucher got like second as a freshman, then had a couple fourth place finishes before he won... i think anyway. he also redshirted one season. he was also more of a 3-5k type. really, i don't see that many similarities. goucher won a few ncaa titles in track before senior year xc.
McDonalds and Goucher college have nothing in common.