Let me put the argument this way:
His cross season was relatively disappointing. He hasn't improved significantly on the track; his times even slipped (slightly) backward in his most recent 10k. He has struggled with injury, multiple stress fractures over the years, pneumonia, sore foot, etc. Staying healthy and focused has been somewhat trying (I don't want to say "difficult", but...)
And now he decides to train and compete in a rather challenging debut marathon at New York. Now, can I ask how he came to this decision? Don't you think it would be better to focus on stringing together a long year of healthy, injury free training -- tweak a few things here or there and maybe that would allow him to break through...perhaps achieving an American record? Instead his brain trust decides to throw him into a marathon training phase that could (and I hate to be pessimistic) cause him CAREER threatening setbacks...He's too young, too physically vulnerable to compete well in the marathon...someday he will be, someday down the line when he's got 5-6 years of healthy, high level training behind him he will be ready to run a very good marathon.
Am I alone on this?