I think you’re understating the difficulty of beating all those guys on the same day, and maybe making too much of DNFing at Worlds. Elites DNF marathons (especially the Olympics and Worlds) and bounce back to their best level all the time.
Like you said, Tola should be considered the favorite. DNFing on a warm, humid day in Budapest doesn’t spoil his resume for the last 3 years:
2021 - 2:03:39 Amsterdam (1st)
2022 - 2:04:14 Tokyo (3rd), 2:05:36 WC (1st), 2:03:40 Valencia (4th)
2023 - 2:04:59 London (3rd), DNF WC
Add in:
- the Olympic silver medalist who ran 2:04:56 last year and 2:05:32 this spring (Nageeye)
- a guy who’s finished top-2 in NYC twice including winning in 2021 (Korir)
- a guy who’s finished 2nd in NYC twice including 2022, and has run one of the fastest times in event history at 2:06:01 (Kitata)
- a guy who’s run a 58:32 half this year and just placed 4th at the World Half 2 weeks ago (not a bad thing) (Yimer)
- a 58:40 half marathoner who won his only marathon this year in Seoul with a 2:05:27 (Walelegn)
- Zouhair Talbi, who was 5th in Boston in his marathon debut
-Edward Cheserek, who is fresh off his best performance in years with a 59:11 half marathon win in Copenhagen
—and Levins’s odds of winning get pretty slim, though, obviously, better than if Chebet, Kamworor and Geremew were still in the race as well