Breaking: Donald Trump vows to return NCAA sports to pre-NIL era within 1 week.

Right, Trump has no skin in this sports game. He probably doesn’t even know the basic rules of a single current NCAA sport or competition. His enacting any kind of law or regulation towards the NCAA will leave him divorced and unaffected by any adverse outcome his EO would cause. He’s like this with everything he does. Other people always pay the penalty for his crimes and decisions.

From the athletes perspective, there is great benefit to "transfer up" from a mid-major to a P4 school.

Nina Cajic started her career at Towson State, and was a CAA player of the year. Then she transferred to Tennessee and became an All American. That was followed by one season with Indy Ignite and she is now playing professionally in Turkey. (That's one of the top two pro leagues in the world.) If she had never transferred from Towson State, she might not be playing professionally today. Playing in SEC gave her the exposure she needed to become a pro.

https://women.volleybox.net/nina-cajic-p62102

Even if you don't become a pro, transferring up gives you an opportunity to play on a big stage you never get at a mid-major. Molly Davis was a 20ppg scorer and First Team All-MAC. But she decided to become a role player at Iowa, where she played in two Final Fours. She is now an assistant coach at Evansville. We don't know if she would be in that position had she stayed at Central Michigan. We certainly would have never known about her iconic headband.

gopurpleaces.com

Molly Davis - Women's Basketball Coach

After back-to-back appearances in the NCAA National Championship game as a student-athlete at the University of Iowa, Molly Davis joined Robyn Scherr's University

Open link

On the other hand, there are players who transfer to get more playing time.

Elina Aarnisalo averaged 21 mpg and 5 ppg at UCLA as a freshman. But with Charlisse Leger-Walker coming back from her redshirt season, and Geena Kneepkens transferring in, her playing time was expected to diminish. So she entered the portal, and moved to UNC. She averaged 26 mpg and doubled her scoring to 10 ppg as a sophomore. When UCLA and UNC played earlier in the season, she was greeted with love and support from her former coach and teammates who were all happy the transfer worked for her.

espn.com

Elina Aarnisalo - North Carolina Tar Heels Guard - ESPN

View the profile of North Carolina Tar Heels Guard Elina Aarnisalo on ESPN. Get the latest news, live stats and game highlights.

Open link

There are many transfers like this, and former teammates remain friends on separate teams.

This video features Donald Trump hosting a roundtable discussion with major figures in sports and politics to discuss the crisis in college athletics (6:32), driven by endless lawsuits and issues regarding eligibility and Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) (10:07). The meeting highlights the need to protect the traditional system of student-athlete scholarships and the role of colleges as the main feeder system for Olympic sports (6:57 - 21:05).Key Discussions and Participants:
Antitrust Protections & Rules: Senator Marco Rubio and former coach Nick Sabin emphasize the need for antitrust exemptions to allow for a uniform set of rules, noting that current chaotic conditions are destroying the integrity of college sports (20:19, 29:46).
The SCORE Act: Participants discuss utilizing the SCORE Act as a base for legislation to establish regulations on NIL collectives and transfer portals (52:13, 1:31:00).
Economic Crisis: Charlie Baker (NCAA President) notes that $2.3 billion was spent on Olympic sports in FY24, which is currently threatened by the financial strain on schools (41:47).
Future Outlook: Ted Cruz warns that if Congress doesn't act soon, college sports could become a system dominated only by a few mini-NFL teams, abandoning smaller institutions (1:21:05).

Based on the roundtable discussion, the goal of the SCORE Act is to establish a comprehensive framework that restores structure to college athletics during a time of chaos and lawsuits (52:13, 1:26:00). Specifically, the act aims to:
Create a national standard for Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) to replace the current patchwork of state laws (57:07, 1:04:02).
Provide antitrust protections to allow the NCAA and conferences to enforce rules regarding transfer portals, compensation caps, and eligibility without fear of constant litigation (57:07, 1:29:55).
Protect student-athletes' ability to graduate by limiting eligibility and regulating transfer rules to prevent endless free agency (31:50, 1:01:23).
Ensure the viability of women's sports and Olympic sports by protecting funding and maintaining Title IX compliance, even while allowing schools to potentially share revenue with athletes (57:07, 1:06:00).

According to the roundtable discussion, the transfer portal is considered destructive for several reasons:
Loss of Educational Focus: Former coach Nick Saban argues that the portal, combined with Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) opportunities, has created a 'pay for play' environment where student-athletes prioritize money over earning a degree (31:50 - 33:00, 1:15:20).
Loss of Team Culture: Urban Meyer suggests the portal leads to a 'loss of locker room' and team cohesion, turning college sports into a transactional business rather than a community experience (1:14:00 - 1:14:30, 1:17:30).
Harm to Athlete Development: Greg Byrne notes that the portal fosters 'pure free agency' where over 4,000 players enter the portal, often without finding a new team, which hampers their ability to graduate and build a legacy (32:00, 1:31:35 - 1:31:50).
Instability for Programs: Commissioner Ted Phillips states that young athletes moving between three or four schools in as many years prevents them from integrating into the community and receiving a proper education (49:48 - 50:15).

Below is the 119th congressional act titled SCORE ACT:

https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/4312/text/rh

Well given his track record on ending the Russia/Ukraine war day one in office, I'm not holding my breath

Trump is going to clean up college sports, meanwhile Donald Trump Jr. is one of the major financial backers of the Enhanced Games. Can't make this s$%^t up

Not if you have a contract. Keep NIL but in the contract - they must stay there for a minimum of 2 years and since they are representing a school- make a C average mandatory. They make their contracts public- make their grades public also . It should not be a one way street as it is now with the athetes. And for added oomph - they are paid 10% of their fee upon signing and they get the rest at the end of the season - too insure they live up to their end of the contract.

She went there to Coach, yikes that was a very bad decision she transferred wayyy down with that choice.

Funny how everyone on this roundtable ither made Millions from college sports or Millions from sports in general, So how are anyone of these people qualified to say who should make money. Not a single student-athlete on the roundtable !!!

don't worry, it's a meaningless round table. nothing will happen

So Karoline Leavitt has become a moderator on a Trump thread. Well done, Letsrun.

It's been one week, and we've got... another empty promise to toss on the heap.

the only people who even took this seriously are those who simply believe every word trump says... unfortunately, it's like 33% of voters

It can be put alongside his claim that he is going to win the war against Iran and was going to end the war in Ukraine on "day one". There is nothing more empty than a Trump promise.

bump for 10 weeks

The executive order was issued on April 3, 2026. The effective date is August 1, 2026.