1) How would the race or I get sued if I raced with someone else's bib? 2) Give 3 examples of this happening.
It's not as much about litigation as it is about catastrophic health emergencies and being able to locate contact and health information quickly. There are bound to be health emergencies when you've got a mass of people in one place, and insurance companies have a formula for figuring out the risk. Having one's name/address/emergency contact, etc. readily available can be extremely helpful in an emergency situation.
I mean sure, the race can point to the waiver that participants sign to try wiggle out of potential lawsuits ("hah, you signed a waiver saying we're not liable for anything"), but health emergencies are the primary concern (and litigation arising from the care & treatment situations).
Among other things, it would be unfortunate if Matt Choi collapsed with a significant medical condition and the hospital Matt was transferred to was under the faulty assumption that Matt was Eric Lee, etc. etc.
There is a place for all that info on the back of most race bibs.
The risk calculated by insurance companies isn't going to change with one runner switching out a bib with another runner.
Do you have multiple examples for these incidents happening? There are millions of race finishes each year in the US. Surely, if this is a problem, examples are in the 100s.
People like Matt reek of BS so I'm not necessarily surprised this came out. He's as corny as SJD but at least Seth is a legitimate runner and has only in the last few years lost his marbles. He's got a great success story, a cult following, good looking guy that sells snake oil to people.
He didn't try to hide his bib swap because his followers are too enamored with him to remotely consider a different perspective.
Can we stop giving idiots like this a platform?
Minus HellahGood and Kofuzi, all these YouTube average Joe's are goobers and liars and cornballs alike
Also, I don't particularly like matt, but Derek has really sunk to the bottom of the barrel with this. He has always maintained that he tries to reach out to the suspect to get their side of the story. I don't know how he would expect someone recovering from a marathon and running a full time business to respond to emails from randos within 2 days. Literally zero "investigation" going on here. He couldn't even contact HM RDs to see what happened?
There is a place for all that info on the back of most race bibs.
The risk calculated by insurance companies isn't going to change with one runner switching out a bib with another runner.
Do you have multiple examples for these incidents happening? There are millions of race finishes each year in the US. Surely, if this is a problem, examples are in the 100s.
Dude, I'm not defending the no race bib transfer policy, or chastising bandits. I don't think this situation is a big deal, nor do I generally think banditing is horrible with a few exceptions like the college idiot who bandited a high school state championship meet.
Anyone who happens to be at the race can sue the event, not just registered waiver signing participants. A random spectator that slips and falls on the sidewalk. A hungover bar patron that walks into the bike pacer.
HOWEVER, having correct participant information is important in emergency situations. You're purposely being dense if you're going to argue this.
Exactly You make that deal with yourself - I may not be able to race, this money may go down the rover. But I want to run THIS race, so it's worth the risk.
It sucks to think that I'm gonna run in Mesa in February, and however many mules, or fast runners on borrowed bibs, or people doing someone a favour, that I'm running against as I try to qualify for Boston and do well in my age category, that a bunch of you here are all okay with them doing that. Just play by the dang rules. They apply to everyone.
Exponentially more people weasel their way into Boston doing a downhill course like Mesa than they do from bib swapping with nefarious motives.
Aw c'mon, man
I was out by 58 seconds in Philly. I'm borderline fast. I'm running Paris too. I'm gonna run as many as it takes.
So much hate and meanness on this forum. Heck. Where's all y'all's running endorphins?
There is a place for all that info on the back of most race bibs.
The risk calculated by insurance companies isn't going to change with one runner switching out a bib with another runner.
Do you have multiple examples for these incidents happening? There are millions of race finishes each year in the US. Surely, if this is a problem, examples are in the 100s.
Dude, I'm not defending the no race bib transfer policy, or chastising bandits. I don't think this situation is a big deal, nor do I generally think banditing is horrible with a few exceptions like the college idiot who bandited a high school state championship meet.
Anyone who happens to be at the race can sue the event, not just registered waiver signing participants. A random spectator that slips and falls on the sidewalk. A hungover bar patron that walks into the bike pacer.
HOWEVER, having correct participant information is important in emergency situations. You're purposely being dense if you're going to argue this.
You're the one arguing that insurance companies risk calculations are inaccurate if someone bib swaps, correct?
http://www2.timesdispatch.com/news/2012/may/17/tdmet01-unregistered-runner-sues-richmond-mud-run--ar-1920375/A man who ran the Filthy 5K Mud Run in 2010 and wound up partially paralyzed when he landed awkwardly in a man-made...
I was out by 58 seconds in Philly. I'm borderline fast. I'm running Paris too. I'm gonna run as many as it takes.
So much hate and meanness on this forum. Heck. Where's all y'all's running endorphins?
The point was not “meanness” it was to say that I don’t see you as having any moral high ground this guy.
Because one of my 5 marathons this year is a fast course? Get a grip. I'll run anywhere they let me and I'm following all the rules. Choi got DQ'd out of a sanctioned race Everyone’s got the same list of races to choose from, the understanding is we do it like we signed up to do it. I’m running the NYC 9+1 program this year and a guy I know and like approached me and offered to run some of my races. I declined. No harm done if you do it, I suppose, and it’s personally a pain in the hoop getting to NYC 5 or so times this year. But those are the rules. I understand people that are tempted by this – and there’s probably no places being stolen from anyone else – but still, man. You gotta earn things the right way. This is the weirdest forum. Calling people who run in qualifying races ‘weasels’ Does anyone remember laughter?
Most events SHOULD allow transfers. Whether they do or not is another question.
Unless this guy was deliberately trying to falsely qualify a friend for Boston, this is a non-story. I have lost hundreds of dollars of marathon race entry fees after getting a severe sinus infection last year and a IT band injury this year and am fed up. His buddy probably wasn't able to run for some reason and gave him the bib to save him a couple hundred bucks. A victimless crime and definitely not worthy of a marathoninvestigation article. Just give me a break.
I disagree that bib transfers should always be allowed. Sure, it would be nice, but it does come at an administrative cost, so all else equal, adding this feature can make race entry fees more expensive.
I would have no problem with the race charging an administrative fee. So, instead of being out $150 - $200, you could pay $10 - $20 to transfer the bib to a friend as a gift, or sell it. Some races do this.
The point isn't that bib swapping is "a big deal" or the end of the world. No one thinks it's a mortal sin. It's just kind of dumb. You go through all the trouble to run your own running youtube channel and you don't bother to sign up for the race? Uh..you can do better than that.
You're not going to burn in hell for borrowing a bib. But people will think, "You just bragged to everyone about achieving a goal, it looked like you did, but then you got disqualified? Uh, lol. That was kind of dumb."
I would have no problem with the race charging an administrative fee. So, instead of being out $150 - $200, you could pay $10 - $20 to transfer the bib to a friend as a gift, or sell it. Some races do this.
It’s a nice service of races that offer it, sure. I could see it messing up high demand races though, since it might make a secondary market crop up for bibs to sought after or prestigious races. It also might impact the number of initial registrants to allow (which would shrink) given that RDs likely count on some attrition and no-shows prior to race day when determining how many people to let sign up.
The point isn't that bib swapping is "a big deal" or the end of the world. No one thinks it's a mortal sin. It's just kind of dumb. You go through all the trouble to run your own running youtube channel and you don't bother to sign up for the race? Uh..you can do better than that.
You're not going to burn in hell for borrowing a bib. But people will think, "You just bragged to everyone about achieving a goal, it looked like you did, but then you got disqualified? Uh, lol. That was kind of dumb."
I will absolutely not have any diminished thoughts about a person's time on the clock based on them not signing up and using a friend's bib who did sign up but can't/isn't running. So what.
This demonstrates the big problem. The registrant signs the waiver.
What are you going to do, require DNA samples and a family tree at the starting line? If you mule a bib there is no way the race is responsible for you.
There is a difference between being cautious and changing the way you do everything based of paranoid fantasies about what might be possible. Let them mule the bib, if they get caught, DQ; if they don't get caught, send it to Boston.