smd wrote:
Pritchard is one of those guys who raises the eternal issue: Does he really believe this bullshit, or does he know he's full of shit, and which is worse?
There can't be too many deliberate scam artists in athletics. The internet has given too many committed athletes a chance to expose obvious fraudulence. Brooks Johnson might be a clever scammer, but my guess is he doesn't have the wherewithal to plan anything as elaborate as a scam. He's a JV clown who believes that having a physical paper called a "diploma" on the wall automatically confers an education (a la the scarecrow in The Wizard of Oz) or that calling a cow's tail a leg makes it a leg. What he is is a talented BSer whose sole objective is to appear authoritative. Once in control, retention of the authority is the measure of productivity and other positive results. Brooks Johnson can sod off.
(Carefully hidden somewhere in there was a subtle hint that I like to bash Brooks Johnson. See if you can spot it.)
As for the "newfangled miracle cure" salesmen - Owen Anderson, Marshall Burt, Richard Gibbens, etc. - they don't seem like deliberate BSers or con men. Though exasperatingly intractable, they probably mean well at some level. They've investigated a (relatively puny) number of options and have hit upon an idea or two that have such effective short-term applications that some impish voice in their heads screams, "Herein must lie the Holy Grail." They support the ideas with science which isn't spurious but is of extremely narrow scope (as most lab science is by inherently restrictive parameters). Unfortunately, these poor, misguided souls have enough experience in the sport to believe their experience is extensive. In reality, their limited experience renders them too shortsighted to know they're shortsighted. Runners have been refining these principles by trial and error for decades and have pretty well narrowed down how and when to use them.
Like actual "miracle cures," some of which do have a few minor medicinal properties, the "do less, get faster" principle has some effective applications - but only if it's part of a well-balanced regimen. Look at it this way - if you get suckered by Kevin Trudeau's infomercials, you might start thinking you could live forever in perfect health if you replace your entire diet with oil of oregano capsules or ginseng root. But it doesn't work that way.