Caster Semenya wife is pregnant..

Armin Tamzarian wrote:

Ben Franklin wrote:

Women can't impregnate other women. Squares are not circles.

In Semenya's case, he/she is intersex so it is a bit more complicated.

It's not complicated. She's a woman. She should run against women.

If you find that complicated, you might be an idiot.

Repeating things 3 times doesn't make it any more true.

And honestly, the people whose default argument is to call others 'idiots' usually aren't the sharpest tools in the shed.

Caster is intersex, has XY chromosomes and internal testes.

So Caster should NOT compete against regular XX women.

End of thread.

Charlesvdw wrote:

Caster is intersex, has XY chromosomes and internal testes.

So Caster should NOT compete against regular XX women.

End of thread.

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Full disclosure. I have fathered at least 4 babies for lesbian couples.

In this day and age, it's the uterus that's the key organ in gestating a fetus and giving birth, not the ovaries. With assisted reproductive technologies, many women who can't produce viable eggs from their own ovaries are nonetheless able to give birth with eggs from another woman's ovaries so long as they have a uterus.

Without a uterus, a woman with normally functioning ovaries pumping out tons of viable/fertile eggs still would not be able to "carry a child" and "give birth."

The issue of whether Semenya, who is said to have 5-ARD - a condition that occurs in both sexes but is a DSD in males only - is murkier.

But you are making a very big and perhaps erroneous assumption when you say Semenya's testes are internal, meaning inside the abdomen. My understanding of 5-ARD in males is that in most cases, the testes at birth are merely undescended - meaning they are located in the external groin skin but not inside the scrotal sacs/scrotum where they normally are placed, a condition known as cryptorchidism.

In fact, experts on 5-ARD say that "in most instances, the testes are located in the inguinal region" - meaning the groin, an outer part of the body, rather than inside the abdominal cavity.

(BTW, cryptorchidism is said to affect 1-2% of male newborns, most of whom do not have DSDS like Semenya.)

The scientific papers I've read and the DSD advocates and experts I've spoken to are mixed about whether males with 5-ARD can provide viable sperm. Many say they can, but they also say that 5-ARD males produce seminal fluid of low viscosity and volume - and sperm of low motility and/or number.

In any event, it seems that from the cases that have been documented, males with 5-ARD who have successfully impregnated women have usually employed assisted reproductive methods such as IUI/ICI or IVF. Then again, this perception might come from the fact that 5-ARD males who need medical assistance with insemination are the only ones showing up in fertility clinics and being documented in studies.

Interestingly, the MtF trans runner Joanna Harper - a source the bigwigs at LRC and site users long have regarded as credible - as well as the longstanding MtF website Susan's Place say that males with 5-ARD can usually produce viable sperm and father children if they use assisted reproductive methods and tech.

Oops, left out the link to the relevant page on Susan's Place:

https://www.susans.org/wiki/5-alpha-reductase_deficiency

Imagine Bruce Jenner identified as female in 1976, the heptathlon record would be out of reach, but I guess he was good enough as a male anyway.

As Dave Chapelle puts it, there is more of an outcry against trans discrimination than racial discrimination, so blacks should be dressing up as trannies to be safe from cops.

Back to Caster, it is an unfortunate condition -disability in fact to have, that because it affects sex organs, it somehow is 'not a disability' and one must change your language around it.

Bloke without sight....".into the blind section of para-lympics, please"

Girl without legs...."over there with the others with prosthetics please"

XY person with undescended testes...." ok, choose what sex you are and join the others. Female? ok, that's fine, I'm sure you other girls are ok with her beating you, right"?

Caster firstly wore boys uniform at school, then progressed through athletics as a woman, and now identifies as woman, but as the husband in marriage.

I think there are bigger issues in the world to be fixed than kowtowing to this sort of f**k*d up Sh*t

I identify as a horse. Place your bets on me at the Preakness Stakes. World has gone crazy. Its like the fable of the frog in the boiling pot....it would jump right out. Years and years of slowly turning up the heat of lunacy and we're all being boiled alive as nd don't even know it. Caster is a biological man. Period.

Caster is 46XY and is therefore a man! Men have naturally high testosterone levels!

Unfortunately the ambiguous genitalia at birth meant Caster was brought up as a woman. However her biology and life choices indicate maleness.

Just Google 'Semenya Wedding Pictures' .

Watch Semenya interact with other runners after races. Look at the physique, flat chest and listen to the deep voice.

Blatantly the sperm that helped produce the baby came from Semenya's testicles.

Once you just accept Semenya is a man, it all just makes sense.

I'm a vegan because the steak that I just ate identifies as a tomato.

Took you 3 years to come up with that, did it?

It is not a genetic trait, it was caused by DDT spraying in her parents homesteads before or while her mother was pregnant. There are tens of thousands like her in those areas affected by malaria mosquito where the government still sprays DDT in the homesteads to this day. Boggles the mind! But here she is fighting for others like her, try stopping the DDT spraying then not going to court to further your cheating. Y chromosome and testes = biological male no matter how one identifies or what genitalia you have.

3 years and few months..That's why it shines with so much universal truth!