Sauer got hit hard, but he's also a damn good appellate lawyer, and he got his points in.
I don't think Gorsuch was buying what the government was saying.
Sauer said that it's the domicil of the mother that matters, not the father. So that cuts down the work some of you MAGAs with more sketchy backgrounds need to do. Just worry about what you can prove your mother was doing in America at the time of your alleged birth, not your dad. Fathers are irrelevant on these citizenship matters according to the US government.
DEI Thomas thinks the 14th Amendment is about freed slaves and nothing else.
Sauer asked the court to rule only prospectively. I wish some Justice has said "WTF? How? How the fvck would it even be possible to rule on a Constitutional Amendment prospectively only?"
Kavanaugh seemed sold on the universally understood holding of the Wong Bing Ching Chong case.
Barrett seemed skeptical of the government's case.
One attendee at the SCOTUS reported on social media that Trump was playing with his phone for the first 20 minutes and the bailiffs were too scared to tell him to stop. Beep beep beep. Then, apparently, he fell asleep for the remainder and spittle was drooling down the left side of his chin onto his tie. Some appearance he made. How much did that cost the taxpayer hauling him down to the SCOTUS so he could snooze? Jesus Christ.
Alito believes that if another country can claim an American born baby as a citizen of the other country, then the American born baby cannot be American. He's losing his mind. American citizenship is determined by a foreign country's desires? How the hell would that work?
I think it goes 7-2, and the only thing of interest will be what kind of activist dissenting opinion Alito can write about irrelevant stuff like lax immigration laws and Chinese birth tourists. It's worth noting that his parents were from Italy, which was an enemy of America during WWII. So maybe ICE needs to pay him a visit to discuss things a bit.