Ran this sceneraio by an Investment Banker in the family circle and their perspective was interesting. In their view, cash reserves should be included as well in the calculation since even cash earns interest and if one chooses to park some of their resources there, that should be captured in their performance calculation.
I guess it all comes down to how you want to define it, but their viewpoint seems to emphesize that everything is in play. I don't know - maybe that's how we should look at these things...
It is more in line with the point's Agip raises.
I think we all should have 3-6m of cash in a n emergency fund. That doesn’t count as investment.
anything above and beyond that, money meant to be used later, counts. Doesn’t matter if it’s cash, bonds, stock, gold, Lamborghinis or Gibsons.
One of these things is not like the others. One of these things just isn't the same. Can you tell me which one is not like the others, before I finish this song?
Hint: CASH is not like the others. All of the others are purchased as INVESTMENTS or at least could be (cars and guitars). Cash is not an investment and is never expected to be under any circumstances.
Historically, the three main asset classes have been equities (stocks), fixed income (bonds), and cash equivalent or money market instruments.
Cash and cash equivalents represent actual cash on hand and securities that are similar to cash. This type of investment is considered very low risk since there is little to no chance of losing your money. That peace of mind means the returns are also lower than other asset classes. Examples of cash and cash equivalents include cash parked in a savings account as well as U.S. government Treasury bills (T-bills), guaranteed investment certificates (GICs), and money market funds. Generally, the greater the risk of losing money, the greater the prospective return.
First day of December and a little check in (Note: I didn't count my coin jar or any other such non-investments in this...just for transparency.):
Dow YTD: UP 19.16%
Flagpole YTD: UP 19.36%
So, for now, I'm ahead. What will the end of the year bring? Doesn't matter to me, but whatever it is, it WILL rile some of you up. I don't understand that, but whatever. Maybe worry about your damn selves.
First day of December and a little check in (Note: I didn't count my coin jar or any other such non-investments in this...just for transparency.):
Dow YTD: UP 19.16%
Flagpole YTD: UP 19.36%
So, for now, I'm ahead. What will the end of the year bring? Doesn't matter to me, but whatever it is, it WILL rile some of you up. I don't understand that, but whatever. Maybe worry about your damn selves.
Hilarious. Just hilarious. You are posting the wrong YTD total return for the Dow. The YTD total return for the Dow is 21.21%. You need to google "total return." Your "beating the Dow 33 out of 35 years" is just garbage. You are just looking at the index appreciation but neglecting to add in the dividends. Hilarious, Flagpole!
I am not able to link sites on the computer but go to "Dow Jones Industrial Average total return performance and stats." Be sure to click on "returns" and select "YTD."
First day of December and a little check in (Note: I didn't count my coin jar or any other such non-investments in this...just for transparency.):
Dow YTD: UP 19.16%
Flagpole YTD: UP 19.36%
So, for now, I'm ahead. What will the end of the year bring? Doesn't matter to me, but whatever it is, it WILL rile some of you up. I don't understand that, but whatever. Maybe worry about your damn selves.
Hilarious. Just hilarious. You are posting the wrong YTD total return for the Dow. The YTD total return for the Dow is 21.21%. You need to google "total return."
I don't NEED to do anything. I can weigh my returns against ANYTHING I like. I can weigh them against numbers of stupid MAAGs if I want...in that case, I would lose BIGLY.
Hilarious. Just hilarious. You are posting the wrong YTD total return for the Dow. The YTD total return for the Dow is 21.21%. You need to google "total return."
I don't NEED to do anything. I can weigh my returns against ANYTHING I like. I can weigh them against numbers of stupid MAAGs if I want...in that case, I would lose BIGLY.
Soooo you are not comparing your portfolio's performance against the actual Dow performance for the year? You are using an inaccurate number for the Dow. Hey, do what you wanna do.
I don't NEED to do anything. I can weigh my returns against ANYTHING I like. I can weigh them against numbers of stupid MAAGs if I want...in that case, I would lose BIGLY.
Soooo you are not comparing your portfolio's performance against the actual Dow performance for the year? You are using an inaccurate number for the Dow. Hey, do what you wanna do.
Soooo you are not comparing your portfolio's performance against the actual Dow performance for the year? You are using an inaccurate number for the Dow. Hey, do what you wanna do.
INCORRECT!
Dow YTD: UP 19.16%
Wrong. The correct Dow Jones YTD TOTAL return for 2024 is 21.21%.
flagpole man you are digging your heels in on things you should not dig your heels in on.
take a deep breath, write down pros and cons
argue the other side and see how that sound to you.
you are being irrational and dogmatic on a couple things.
I know you don't want to be that.
Although Flagpole has a methodist background, he comes across more Woodrow Wilson (presbyterian) than John Wesley. This H.L. Mencken quote from Puritanism As a Literary Force describes him well; "his unmatchable intolerance of opposition, his unbreakable belief in his own bleak and narrow views, his savage cruelty of attack, ...—these things have put an almost unbearable burden upon the exchange of ideas in the United States"
Detroit stays ahead of the game 💰 Starting in 2025, we’re making history as the largest U.S. city to accept crypto payments for taxes and city fees. Blockchain meets the Motor City—this is innovation with grit.
I have no idea what Bitcoin's high will be in 2025. I think it'll be a bull market but there's always the potential of a bear market. And if the US government as a whole - instead of Detroit lol - accepts it it'd certainly rise
If I'd have to guess I'd view $110k as a low end and $200k as a high end. $140 is my prediction
flagpole man you are digging your heels in on things you should not dig your heels in on.
take a deep breath, write down pros and cons
argue the other side and see how that sound to you.
you are being irrational and dogmatic on a couple things.
I know you don't want to be that.
INCORRECT!
I can measure my returns in any way I choose.
Dow YTD: UP 19.16%
FP, Yes you can measure your returns in any way you choose, but comparisons by their very nature assume consistent metrics. You insist on using a dissimilar metric from that of the DJIA. Your portfolio assumes dividend reinvestment in the calculation and the form of the DJIA index you compare it to DOES NOT.
It is this simple, for the purposes of comparing race times, everyone agrees to use Gun Time, but you insist on using Chip Time. And it is not a fair comparison for that reason. If you want to keep using your method, you should make it clear every single time that you note the comparison that you are not making an accurate(equal) comparison and why. To hide this fact is disingenuous to say the least.
It is easy to get the Total Return (included Dividend reinvestment) by simply googling Total Return DJIA, click YTD time frame, and divide ending number by the Jan.1 number. I just did it and it is in fact 21%.
FP, Yes you can measure your returns in any way you choose, but comparisons by their very nature assume consistent metrics. You insist on using a dissimilar metric from that of the DJIA. Your portfolio assumes dividend reinvestment in the calculation and the form of the DJIA index you compare it to DOES NOT.
It is this simple, for the purposes of comparing race times, everyone agrees to use Gun Time, but you insist on using Chip Time. And it is not a fair comparison for that reason. If you want to keep using your method, you should make it clear every single time that you note the comparison that you are not making an accurate(equal) comparison and why. To hide this fact is disingenuous to say the least.
It is easy to get the Total Return (included Dividend reinvestment) by simply googling Total Return DJIA, click YTD time frame, and divide ending number by the Jan.1 number. I just did it and it is in fact 21%.
It is actually even easier than that. Go to that site. Click on YTD and then click on "Returns" right next to "Level" and then Voila! There you have it.
FP, Yes you can measure your returns in any way you choose, but comparisons by their very nature assume consistent metrics. You insist on using a dissimilar metric from that of the DJIA. Your portfolio assumes dividend reinvestment in the calculation and the form of the DJIA index you compare it to DOES NOT.
It is this simple, for the purposes of comparing race times, everyone agrees to use Gun Time, but you insist on using Chip Time. And it is not a fair comparison for that reason. If you want to keep using your method, you should make it clear every single time that you note the comparison that you are not making an accurate(equal) comparison and why. To hide this fact is disingenuous to say the least.
It is easy to get the Total Return (included Dividend reinvestment) by simply googling Total Return DJIA, click YTD time frame, and divide ending number by the Jan.1 number. I just did it and it is in fact 21%.
It is actually even easier than that. Go to that site. Click on YTD and then click on "Returns" right next to "Level" and then Voila! There you have it.
Understood, but the site I was on just happened to require a subscription to do so, and it's easy enough to just plug the numbers in in lieu of having it kick them our for us.
Edit: Ok, found the icon to click on the site you referenced earlier, and here it is. Just click RETURNS on the top of the page and select YTD:
Instead of the DJIA I compare my performance against the DOW30 tracking ETF DIA. The ETF is investable, has a management fee and pays a dividend therefore replicates what I am doing. Total returns for the ETF are easy to calculate and I'm comparing dollars to dollars and not dollars to points
flagpole man you are digging your heels in on things you should not dig your heels in on.
take a deep breath, write down pros and cons
argue the other side and see how that sound to you.
you are being irrational and dogmatic on a couple things.
I know you don't want to be that.
Although Flagpole has a methodist background, he comes across more Woodrow Wilson (presbyterian) than John Wesley. This H.L. Mencken quote from Puritanism As a Literary Force describes him well; "his unmatchable intolerance of opposition, his unbreakable belief in his own bleak and narrow views, his savage cruelty of attack, ...—these things have put an almost unbearable burden upon the exchange of ideas in the United States"
Lake Flagpole: “where all the women are strong, all the men are good-looking, all the children are above average, and all your investments beat the Dow.”
Help us build the best running shoe review site for a chance to win a LetsRun t-shirt.Help us build the best running shoe review site for a chance to win one of 10 LetsRun t-shirts.