Crosstrek will get you laid-- A LOT, especially the new 2018. The 2017 Impreza hatchback is excellent too though it only offers five speed manual, not six. To my surprise, the CVT in both cars is impressive though if you're coming from a bigger enging with turbo you might want horsepower.
oil burning was an issue but not a recent one-- it peaked c. 1999-2000-- nor ultimately that big a deal. But, because it's an easy way to beat up on what's generally a superior car manufacturer, it gets trotted out as above.