A worthwhile articulation of a tendency to both hold up a mirror and to understand MAGA:
"As someone who participates in debate (real debate, not the Charlie Kirk version), I am always researching the psychological underpinnings of why people believe what they do, how to expose flawed reasoning, etc.
Quickly, I learned that what people say they believe isn’t what they actually believe. What they say is a protective mechanism for their deeper, irrational beliefs.
Here, the belief is: “I don’t like him, I don’t care.”
The fact that this is the “most reasonable excuse” illustrates their desperation.
The “most reasonable excuse” fallacy — aka the self-strawman — is intended to provide layers of protection by stating a belief that does not challenge the true belief.
The true belief is, consciously or subconsciously, irrational or indefensible.
When people argued the COVID vaccine wasn’t FDA approved, a normal person would read that to mean: “So once it’s FDA approved, you’ll get it?”
But no. It was, at the time, simply the most reasonable excuse to shield the real belief:
Not getting it, no matter what.
Some of you may find it obvious, others surprising:
The vast majority of MAGA doesn’t think Renée Good had malicious intent, nor that she was using her car as a weapon, nor that the officer felt threatened for his life.
These are all excuses that, in these circumstances, shield the true belief: “I don’t care that the officer shot her.”
But the Pretti case is especially egregious.
When their best excuse is “but he was armed” — something they love — it shows how deeply desperate they are.
Oh, and in case you were wondering, just like with the COVID vaccine being FDA approved, there is nothing that will get these people to change their mind. They simply move the goalposts.
Protection of the belief is more important than valid reasoning.
If Pretti didn’t have a weapon, they’d have simply said his resisting was justification. Or that he reached for an officer’s weapon.
There are no depths too low for these people." - Carl Allen