a16minrunner wrote:
How the hell can you say he is a better runner that what he displayed today? He ran a race, did his best, thats what he is!
I ran a pr of 16:20 for 5k today but I am a better runner than that so I will change my handle to a15minrunner!
Uh, because he ran over 10 minutes faster than that in his marathon debut, and his 10k times, half marathon times, etc. convert to much faster.
As for the guy saying the 2:22 prediction was so clever... well done. She cleverly hedged her bets in case of bad conditions. The kid had been running well, this contest is for fun (unless you really take that $50 bucks seriously), and it was a cool way for people to show their support and try to predict what time he would run. All recent racing results for Fasil pointed to a fast performance... it's a shame about the heat.
My point (and that of Fasil's brother) is that there is no way one would reasonably expect Fasil to run 2:22. He could do that as a tempo run (if he went out at 5:23 pace or whatever it is). Thus, it's kind of a dick thing to do to predict such a slow time. But again, if your main goal is to be clever and try to win $50, so be it. Congrats to her, but she is certainly not owed an apology of any kind.
Again, best wishes to Fasil, Meb, and the other guys who had a rough day.