"Dave Davis? Ahman Dirks? Who the hell are these guys? I just had a discussion with my significant other and she made a remark about, "well 13:36 or 38 (Johnson and Donnelly) isn?t that bad." But is it good? Have these guys improved?...."
NIKE:
I don't wish to state my opinion of the Nike Oregon project, as I really don't know much at all about it. However, one of the guys you mention, Ahman Dirks, I know a little about, having seen him locally and met him on several occasions. I think if you knew his background, you'd have to mark him down as a success story for the Oregon project. I don't know the exact details of his running career, but I think it was about like this: went to University of Puget Sound, pretty good runner on the regional level, but I doubt he ever ran much under 14:30 for a 5000. I think he was more of a 1500 runner, with a PR in the mid to high 3:40's if I recall correctly. Post-graduating he was just sort of running for himself, and eventually started training with the Oregon project guys. Now I don't know what his arrangement with them was or is, but I'm pretty sure he wasn't actually a "member" of the group, and wasn't recruited. He was just a guy who was fast enough to run some of their workouts, thus useful enough to have around. I believe he actually benefitted quite a lot from being around Salazar, as Salazar basically let him know he was kidding himself with the training he had previously been doing, and got him to start running 100 mile weeks on a regular basis. He's become a much better distance runner over the last couple of years, turning in a 13:53 indoors or thereabouts. I saw that he ran 13:39 down at Mt. SAC, which I think is actually a big breakthrough for him. I guess he's running well enough now for the Project to associate his name with them.
So basically, it seems that for him, the Oregon Project helped him tremendously, turning him from a fairly talented but inconsistent and poorly trained runner into a guy on the verge of being a true stud. And isn't that the goal of all these training groups? As far as Dave Davis goes, I don't know all that much about him, but you make it sound like he's a total unknown. I'm pretty sure he qualified for the World XC team, maybe even at both distances, a couple of years ago just out of college, so whatever you think of him, you can at least understand that he would have seemed like a good runner for the Oregon Project to take in. As for whether he has benefitted, I have no idea.
Anyway, I assume you weren't trying to insult them personally, just wondering who they were and why they were on the team. In Ahman's case at least, the Oregon Project seems to have been a success. And Dan Brown seems to be thriving, so I guess you would have to conclude that the group has had at least 2 success stories.