fastboy77 wrote:
Are you a Lydiard's guy that believes in periodization? Or do you believe aerobic capacity, anaerobic development, and speed can all be developed at once? I like Lydiard but im not a fan on the periodization but I like that breakdown that he has just squeezed into one week.
I definitely wouldn't identify much with Lydiard beyond thinking that most American runners (High School and College) still aren't running enough volume. In my experience most HS programs don't ask their kids to run more than 30 miles a week for girls or 40 a week for boys even if they're clearly great athletes. I ran 40 a week in HS and was fortunate that I was talented. Kids who can't rely on talent need to improve some other way, it's not by training like the kids that can get away with doing less and still being good.
I also wouldn't say those three things should always be developed at the same time, though usually we're playing with a lot of them in varying doses.
Aerobic capacity and speed development play well with one another in a "base phase." Yes, they're largely different fiber types and mechanisms, but they don't have problems coexisting in the same training phases.
Anaerobic development and Speed Development are also fine together.
Aerobic capacity and anaerobic development are more at odds with one another. We're getting in the weeds with terminology on "aerobic capacity" but generally aerobic changes don't play as nicely with anaerobic stimulus. This is the part where Lydiard comes in again. I wouldn't have anything challenging for the anaerobic system while we're building up; there's no need at that time. When we get to the middle of the season we'll be ramping up on anaerobic work gradually and our aerobic work takes a step up in quality with workouts over the longer mileage or less structured sessions.
That said, I have seen some programs take the "develop everything" approach too far for my tastes. You can fit almost any workout into any phase of training with some tweaks.
Early/off season: 12x200m at mile pace w/ 400m jog
Mid-season: 20x200m at mile pace w/ 200m jog
late season: 2 sets 8x200m at mile pace w/ 30s rest (6 min. between sets)
Not necessarily workouts I would do, but someone coaches see 200's and think that they're going to peak too soon. Others would look at this and call each of them pretty tame considering how short 200m really is for a moderately fast rep. They can all have their place and you can just as easily say, "why bother with the first workout over having regular strides and a solid tempo run instead?"
That was a few tangents, but let me know if there's any other way I can help out.