Luv2Run wrote:
If we started from scratch, I would say have a "Y" and "non-Y" split. If your cheek swab shows a "Y" chromosome then that is your division.
Start from "scratch"? This is what they used to do at the Olympics. IOC stopped doing this in 90s for a good reason.
Viking21 wrote:
I am not female and I'm only competitive in the old folk's class. I guess that means my opinion on the matter has no value to you. I coach high school girls. I see the work they put in and the sacrifices they make. I also see their reluctance to make waves in the face of woke culture. Privately, they all think it's unfair for biological males to compete in their classes. As their coach, I am willing to speak for them.
Of course, young women and girls cannot speak for themselves. So they always need men to speak for them. If they ever speak up in support of trans athletes, that's because they are feeling the pressure from the woke culture. They don't even know what they privately want, but adult men do. That's why they always need adult men's guidance and supervision.
Just Another Hobby Jogger wrote:
Viking21 wrote:
I am not female and I'm only competitive in the old folk's class. I guess that means my opinion on the matter has no value to you. I coach high school girls. I see the work they put in and the sacrifices they make. I also see their reluctance to make waves in the face of woke culture. Privately, they all think it's unfair for biological males to compete in their classes. As their coach, I am willing to speak for them.
Of course, young women and girls cannot speak for themselves. So they always need men to speak for them. If they ever speak up in support of trans athletes, that's because they are feeling the pressure from the woke culture. They don't even know what they privately want, but adult men do. That's why they always need adult men's guidance and supervision.
It's sad these young girls have to voice their concern privately as Viking21 mentioned for fear of getting labeled or canceled.
I'm still yet to hear an argument that makes any sort of sense on why a boy who feels like a girl can compete as a girl. Gender dysphoria is a psychological issue, not a biological issue.
Lenny Leonard wrote:
This is old news. And don’t pretend that this isn’t racially motivated. This would not be an issue in states that aren’t predominantly white.
Trans girls are girls. They run against girls. Stop bending everything to your transphobic narrative.
retweet
Full Throttle Blip wrote:
Just Another Hobby Jogger wrote:
Of course, young women and girls cannot speak for themselves. So they always need men to speak for them. If they ever speak up in support of trans athletes, that's because they are feeling the pressure from the woke culture. They don't even know what they privately want, but adult men do. That's why they always need adult men's guidance and supervision.
It's sad these young girls have to voice their concern privately as Viking21 mentioned for fear of getting labeled or canceled.
I'm still yet to hear an argument that makes any sort of sense on why a boy who feels like a girl can compete as a girl. Gender dysphoria is a psychological issue, not a biological issue.
Because stories are how policy is made now, and the Trans folks have the stories to tell about how awful and unfair and how bigoted people are and depression and self harm .....let 'em run with girls you haterzzz.
Lenny Leonard wrote:
This is old news. And don’t pretend that this isn’t racially motivated. This would not be an issue in states that aren’t predominantly white.
This is a bizarre statement. As the issue pertains to gender how is it racially motivated and what states in the US are NOT predominantly white?
Just Another Hobby Jogger wrote:
Viking21 wrote:
I am not female and I'm only competitive in the old folk's class. I guess that means my opinion on the matter has no value to you. I coach high school girls. I see the work they put in and the sacrifices they make. I also see their reluctance to make waves in the face of woke culture. Privately, they all think it's unfair for biological males to compete in their classes. As their coach, I am willing to speak for them.
Of course, young women and girls cannot speak for themselves. So they always need men to speak for them. If they ever speak up in support of trans athletes, that's because they are feeling the pressure from the woke culture. They don't even know what they privately want, but adult men do. That's why they always need adult men's guidance and supervision.
I would suggest that you find somebody to speak for you, provided that you actually have something to say. I'm not speaking for a random monolithic block of girls. I'm doing my best to look out for the interests of my athletes as they present them to me. Did you have no one to confide in as a young girl?
Should be an issue everywhere and no being a trans doesn't change you from a boy to a girl or a girl to a boy.
Tatar wrote:
it is now "name calling" to say someone's a transphobe.
The word "transphobe" is a straw man that responds to an assertion of fact with an argument to motive.
Focusing on it being name-calling instead is another straw man. It may be name calling too, but the more important thing is it's just false. A man who thinks he's a woman isn't, whether he or anyone else wants him to be one or not.
Bad Wigins wrote:
Tatar wrote:
it is now "name calling" to say someone's a transphobe.
The word "transphobe" is a straw man that responds to an assertion of fact with an argument to motive.
Focusing on it being name-calling instead is another straw man. It may be name calling too, but the more important thing is it's just false. A man who thinks he's a woman isn't, whether he or anyone else wants him to be one or not.
It's simple , to say I don't believe males who identify as females should compete with me as a real female, or my daughter or some random girl I empathize with or the collective of random girls I empathize with ,....is not transphobic. it's an opinion the name caller doesn't like and turns to bullying by name calling.
I honestly can't wait for an ex. Men's college power forward to wake up one morning and decide she belongs in the wnba. She could wreck the whole league. That's something I would pay money to see.
ThickThighs wrote:
I honestly can't wait for an ex. Men's college power forward to wake up one morning and decide she belongs in the wnba. She could wreck the whole league. That's something I would pay money to see.
There would be 12 months of hormone treatments between that magical morning and when she could play. It seems odd that you would want to pay to see her play. Are you already an WNBA fan?
ThickThighs wrote:
I honestly can't wait for an ex. Men's college power forward to wake up one morning and decide she belongs in the wnba. She could wreck the whole league. That's something I would pay money to see.
How about when 10-15 of them want to do that? Do it for a few years make some money get off the hormones, try to game the hormone thing as best you can and cry anti-trans if you get caught.
Lenny Leonard wrote:
And don’t pretend that this isn’t racially motivated.
How does transgenderism become racism?
Do Democrats really believe this?
I'm trying to get my head around this.
facts and reason wrote:
Lenny Leonard wrote:
And don’t pretend that this isn’t racially motivated.
How does transgenderism become racism?
Do Democrats really believe this?
I'm trying to get my head around this.
Libs always cry racism when they have no argument.
What about race dysphoria? Serious question. If there's a white guy who genuinely thinks he's black, shouldn't he be able to call himself black on grant applications, job interviews and such?
facts and reason wrote:
Lenny Leonard wrote:
And don’t pretend that this isn’t racially motivated.
How does transgenderism become racism?
Do Democrats really believe this?
I'm trying to get my head around this.
Democrats don't believe being opposed to the existence of transgender is racism. That would be bigotry.
Someone can be opposed to transgender athletes competing against women and not be canceled. Countless state senators have voted to have them banned from womens sports. The reaction to Jenner was that she was a hypocrite.
Lenny Leonard wrote:
This is old news. And don’t pretend that this isn’t racially motivated. This would not be an issue in states that aren’t predominantly white.
Trans girls are girls. They run against girls. Stop bending everything to your transphobic narrative.
This debate, or better yet irrational thought from the "Woke" (Un-Woke) left is over.
No guys who think they're girls and No girls who think they're guys will be allowed to compete in events outside their gender. The hammer has already dropped!
Game, Set, and Match.
NEXT!
facts and reason wrote:
Lenny Leonard wrote:
And don’t pretend that this isn’t racially motivated.
How does transgenderism become racism?
Do Democrats really believe this?
I'm trying to get my head around this.
How does Lenny Leonard become Democrats?
Does "facts and reason" really believe this?
I'm trying to get my head around this.
jonesy22 wrote:
facts and reason wrote:
How does transgenderism become racism?
Do Democrats really believe this?
I'm trying to get my head around this.
Libs always cry racism when they have no argument.
"jonesy 22" always tries to paint a group from one individual's comment.
Try to get a brain.