Mr Obvious wrote:
CAS should not be involved at all in this issue they are not experts.
The science is just that, science, in and of itself is meaningless to the question, CAS set up artificial hurdles they know nothing about, Ross Tucker fell right in line.
The IAAF are the subject matter experts in track and Field and should allowed to determine how to manage the intersection between scientific findings, administrative realities, competitive fairness, spectator interest and the implementation of policy and rules for the sport of track and field without interference from "judges" who lack any sport specific knowledge, CAS should only exist to determine if rules, as written are being procedurally followed, not creating their own rules or setting up the parameters for how the IAAF does there bussiness.
This is a novel position. And, also, with the IAAF’s history of corruption and poor administration, an obviously untenable one. I doubt you’ll have much company in the the-IAAF-should-be-accountable-to-no-one camp.