I agree in 1980 McChesney would have been unlikely to make any impact. I still feel in awe of his running from 1982, probably the greatest year for American 5000 runners with the exception of one meet in Tokyo in 1964.
I was the type of running nerd that put magazine pictures up in my high school locker and along with Cram, Coe, Scott, Maree, Salazar, I recall a great clipping of McChesney in the Santa Monica uni, probably from a preview of the US trials.
That was a hell of a year, 1982. Scott ran 3:47 and I saw them show the finish that night on ABC "Nightline" with Ted Koppel. You had Centrowitz run 13:12, McChesney 13:14 or 15 and Salazar 13:11. Maybe I'm nostalgic because that was around exactly the time I got into the sport but in that era, despite his competitive record at NCAA's or U.S. Nationals that guy still stands out in my mind as impressive, more so than a three-time NCAA winner like Scherer from Michigan.
The top performances in that sport were the 13:00 by Moorcroft(unbelievable at the time) and Rono I think hit 13:06. And a kid in college, or just graduating, runs 13:15 which a year ago would have been an AR.
I know he was a tremendous talent, hard worker, but there are a lot that come through the ranks and don't handle the adjustment well. He ran on an unbelievable Oregon team with Chapa, Salazar, Centrowitz I bet was still around, Ken Martin, Don Clary, then you had fresman like Jeff Nelson, Jim Hill, Zishka transferring over. Those workout must have been wars every week!
McChesney in my mind made his mark. Olympian and near AR 5000 meter holder. If he never won 10 Pac-10 titles or 3 NCAA titles so what. I'd cut my wrist off to run 13:15 and never win a race. Why? Maybe I'm stupid. Just would love to feel how it is to be at that level. To know that at that time only maybe 20 men in the world has ever run that fast.