I ran the Paavo program in high school and since I've graduated I've gone on to work the Paavo Camps as a Coach. The Paavo program is the only program I've spent a significant amount of time with so I know I'm biased.
I always see these threads and feel like I need to say something even though I know most people are already decided on the issue.
First of all, yes the Paavo program is laid out day by day but if you have a coach that doesn't know that he needs to listen and adapt the program to his indivduals than you have a bigger problem than the program you are using. The biggest thing I notice about successful coaches/programs/athletes is their ability to adapt the workout to the situation depending on all kinds of factors. Nothing is set in stone.
Second, yes the PAAVO brand is a business. You have to pay for a seminar or a camp. Just like you have to pay for a Lydiard or Daniels book. Right now Running the Lydiard Way is just as expensive a two day clinic with one on one interaction. It's not a secret. Coach Sellers isn't out trying to hunt down and remove all posts that explain the system. It feels like a secret because you're paying for much more than the nuts and bolts of the program.
This leads me to my last point. What makes Paavo so special to me and all the others in the Paavo "cult" is the lessons and principles that focus on the real world after high school. It's so funny to hear people say Paavo is only good for high school and ruins kids for later when the whole philosphy is about working hard, having a positive attitude and doing the things that will make you successful in life after high school. I am bluring the line a little between running and other things, I know.
Paavo camps give you the chance to do runs that'd you'd never do at a camp on a college campus. Spooner was right when he said people there are serious about running and being a better runner and locations help develop that attitude.
To the original post in this link, you can't base your entire opion of the applicant on Paavo experience in his resume. Do you think he is going to be able to adapt? Did you ask him if he has plans other than just copying the Paavo workouts every week and expecting the kids to just do it. If he really is a Paavo coach he will have a very positive attitude and that is good for any program.
Just know that if he is a Paavo coach he will run the kids on a lydiard based program. He will try to get them to go to the camps, which is an awesome experience and I think runners of any age would really enjoy. If he's a smart Paavo coach he'll adapt the program and give kids a desire to work hard, have a postive attitude and learn how to set goals in running and in life.
This is long and not proofread so please flame on.......now