MS coach wrote:
I coach middle schoolers. If this was my team, I would have pulled the offending athlete aside and had a strong talk with him about character and sportsmanship. Only THEN would I explain the rules and tell the athlete that he/she was disqualified.
Don't make it all about "the rules" - because MS kids likely don't know (or shouldn't be expected to know) all the National Federation Rules. I'm not saying don't FOLLOW the rules (in fact, I'm a stickler for them).... I'm saying it's not really about the rules here, is it.
What it SHOULD be all about is sportsmanship and character. If kids learn that lessons early, they are far less likely to have that issue again - regardless of the sport or circumstance.
Just my two cents. Your kid's coach needs to emphasize right and wrong more than finish times and rules.
As a high school coach, I agree with this for the older kids as well. Kids make mistakes, its part of them growing up. That doesn't mean we shouldn't step in and set them straight. And I think your point that it isn't "about the rules" is spot on. The rules are there to enforce fair behaviour. The fariness is the point, the rule is just a tool.