LetsRun.com Reviewer Ratings

Shoe Comparison

Shoe comparison
HOKA ONE ONE Clifton 5
HOKA ONE ONE Clifton 9
Brooks Ghost 15
HOKA ONE ONE Bondi 8
Image
HOKA ONE ONE Clifton 5
This Shoe
HOKA ONE ONE Clifton 9
Newer Version
Brooks Ghost 15
Top Rated Trainer For Sale
HOKA ONE ONE Bondi 8
Most Comfortable Trainer For Sale
Shoe Properties
Shoe Type
Trainer
Trainer
Trainer
Trainer
Pronation Control
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Weight
9.4 oz. (men's), 7.6 oz. (women's)
10 oz. (men's), 9 oz. (women's)
9.6 oz. (men's), 8.4 oz. (women's)
11.1 oz. (men's), 10.1 oz. (women's)
Stack Height
30mm.
40mm.
35mm.
43mm.
Forefoot Height
25mm.
35mm.
23mm.
39mm.
Drop Height
5 mm.
5 mm.
12 mm.
4 mm.
Upper material
Breathable Engineered Knit Upper, Gusseted Tongue, Reinforced Eyestays
Refined 3D Fit Print mesh, Recycled Materials include:
Engineered mesh, Lycra comfort frame, Internal heel counter, Pillowed Tongue
Shoe Released
Q2 2018
Q1 2023
Q4 2022
Q3 2022
MSRP
$130
$145
$140
$165
LRC Ratings
Out of 10
Overall
8.6
8.9
9.2
9.0
Comfort
8.9
9.2
9.1
9.6
Cushioning
9.8
9.4
9.1
9.6
Durability
8.4
7.9
8.8
8.1
Appearance
8.1
8.6
8.2
7.9
Value
8.2
8.1
8.6
7.7

Reader Reviews

  • Incredibly comfortable

    35 miles per week, overpronator, medium arches
    Overall
    8.0
    Comfort
    10.0
    Cushioning
    10.0
    Durability
    7.0
    Appearance
    8.0
    Value
    7.0

    I bought the Hoka Clifton 5 on sale at my local running store. I wanted to try a pair of Hokas because of how comfortable they looked, and I was not disappointed. These are the most comfortable shoes that I have ever run in. They’re great on long runs, but I would avoid them for any type of track or speed work. The cushioning is great for cool downs and recovery days after hard workouts and races. The durability is good enough, but the outsole wore out fairly quickly. I have about 400 miles on the shoes and there’s basically no tread left in the mid foot area. My biggest complaint is that the toe box is a little roomy, and the shoes give me blisters. Overall, the shoe is amazing and I would definitely run in them again.

  • Hoka One One Clifton 5

    40 miles per week, neutral pronator, low arches
    Overall
    8.0
    Comfort
    8.0
    Cushioning
    10.0
    Durability
    7.0
    Appearance
    8.0
    Value
    9.0

    Has been my go to shoe for the past year. Been a fan of the Clifton's since they started making them in wide. With my hobbit feet and need for cushioning at a decent weight the Clifton's stand out as one of the best options. I've run several marathons in the Cliftons and this is the best of the bunch thus far. I do have a pair of 6's which I haven't tried out yet but a few of the reviews have indicated that the toe area may be more pointed than the 5's. I'll eventually try them out after this pair wears out. But so far so good. Next up for them is Boston '20.

  • Best Daily Trainer I’ve Ran in For a While

    55 miles per week, neutral pronator, low arches
    Overall
    9.0
    Comfort
    8.0
    Cushioning
    10.0
    Durability
    7.0
    Appearance
    6.0
    Value
    9.0

    It was a great shoe that I’m still using 7 months after purchasing it. The cushioning is great, and although it can be a bit too heavy at times, I still feel as though I can use it for just about any run that doesn’t require me to go very fast. Highly recommend

  • Decent long run shoe

    35 miles per week, neutral pronator, medium arches
    Overall
    7.0
    Comfort
    8.0
    Cushioning
    9.0
    Durability
    7.0
    Appearance
    7.0
    Value
    7.0

    Good shoe for long runs. It's obviously quite cushioned, but feels very stable.

  • Smooth Ride

    20 miles per week, neutral pronator, medium arches
    Overall
    9.0
    Comfort
    9.0
    Cushioning
    9.0
    Durability
    9.0
    Appearance
    8.0
    Value
    10.0

    Lightweight

    Smooth Ride

    Breathability

  • Starts out strong; fades too quickly

    20 miles per week, neutral pronator, medium arches
    Overall
    7.0
    Comfort
    7.0
    Cushioning
    7.0
    Durability
    5.0
    Appearance
    7.0
    Value
    7.0

    The first couple of weeks of wearing this shoe are awesome. I only run about 20 mpw these days so in theory my shoes shouldn't need replacing too quickly. What I've found with the Clifton (multiple versions) is that they lose that Hoka cloud-like cushioning too fast. I realize that I'm not a 6% body fat guy anymore and I won't get the kind of life expectancy like I once did but after about 200 miles these shoes feel a bit dead.

  • Great shoe thats always pleasant to run on!

    7 miles per week, low arches
    Overall
    9.0
    Comfort
    10.0
    Cushioning
    9.0
    Durability
    8.0
    Appearance
    7.0
    Value
    7.0

    The shoe has helped me overcome my IT band syndrome due to its forgiving cushioning, which allowed me to retrain my gait without worrying about injury as much as my other shoes. Though the shoe and the cushioning is big, its still super light for what it is!

  • Beautiful Sole, Topped by Vicious Upper

    35 miles per week, neutral pronator, medium arches
    Overall
    7.0
    Comfort
    5.0
    Cushioning
    10.0
    Durability
    8.0
    Appearance
    5.0
    Value
    7.0

    47 y/o male, 168-180#, depending on season. Up to 50-60 mpw at best. I wear D width in Asics and Mizuno, but developed the usual calf/achilles issues a few years ago. Tried out the Clifton 5. I love the rocker sole and cushion. Durability is decent, (got well over 350 miles in first pair).

    But the toebox is awfully narrow, causing blisters on both sides of the ball of my foot. I tried sizing up a half (almost lost a toenail from fore/aft banging) and tried the EE width, which is only barely wider. If the shoe was 5mm wider, I'd buy a dozen pairs today. The Tracer2 is the proper width for me, but they don't have nearly as much cushion and I feel beat up after runs longer than 15M in them.

  • Top dog

    40 miles per week, neutral pronator, high arches
    Overall
    10.0
    Comfort
    10.0
    Cushioning
    10.0
    Durability
    8.0
    Appearance
    10.0
    Value
    9.0

    Amazing shoe

    Hoarded them when Hoka once again stopped making them

  • Allround shoe

    40 miles per week, neutral pronator, medium arches
    Overall
    9.0
    Comfort
    8.0
    Cushioning
    9.0
    Durability
    9.0
    Appearance
    7.0
    Value
    8.0

    Nice shoe with a lot of cushioning. Good for long runs. A litle bit heavy for faster stuff