You are reporting the following post to the moderators for review and possible removal from the forum

George213
RE: Allright Letsrun - Who wins, Ryan Hall 2007 or Galen Rupp in 2017

Raysism wrote:

[quote]Das.Wetter.Stinkt wrote:

Rupp.

Hall's Olympic Trials race was incredible, but it also proves the point. While he was on fire that day, he didn't need to go that fast. I suspect Rupp would have treated that race as business-as-usual, locked up the victory, and saved his "going to the well" for when it really matters.


This is total hindsight rationalization. Ritz's second place time in 2008 was faster than Rupp's winning time in 2016. Hall had to go fast. He was racing a loaded field in 2008 -- literally no one thought he was anything other than genius on that day.

Also, Hall's next race was a 2:06 for 5th place in London, so I'm pretty sure that 2:09 wasn't him "going to the well".

Look, I think Rupp's the greatest US distance runner ever, and totally appreciate the idea that he could come up big against Hall if it mattered. But Hall's marathon resume is far, far superior to Rupp's (he broke 2:08:40 five times -- twice in his first three marathons!), and Rupp has won exactly one race of note. If Hall was the better marathoner at his peak, I think he beats Rupp 6 or 7 out of 10 times.[/quote]
Quite the contrary, with an Olympic medal (which was just his second marathon and preceded by a 10k final) and a WMM win, while Hall has never (and will never) won either. Time-wise, his 2:09 with a 1:03 second half under warm condition indicates he could have run much faster (and this also showed that Rupp can cope with adverse weather as well),
When it comes to the marathon (actually distance running in general) I'd rather have the career of Rupp than Hall.

Hit the submit button below if you want us to review the post.

If you feel this is urgent or want a reply, email us at [email protected] about the post and please include a link to the thread the post is on and what page number/post on that page it is.