That shouldn't freak you out at all. Look back at old results- it is the norm.
Yeah, look at how many of the dudes weren't stars in college. The only one who had a big time college career was Solinsky.
Just like how many Heisman winners have shitty careers in the NFL. And how many runners have great college careers, but disappear after they graduate. It's because sucess at one level does not necessarily translate to sucess at the next.