But the point stands, it doesn't matter how good the kicker is. They Heisman trophy is not given to the Best Player in the League, they already have an award for that. It's given to the most popular player, that's why a kicker can never win it... They could never be that popular. It doesn't matter how good they are. If they were freakishly athletic at a young age and playing football, they probably would have gotten converted to another position.