jesseriley wrote:
I’ve received additional reports, mostly via twitter accounts (because organizers have deleted everything they could control).
Both runners have released statements. The consensus is the organizers looked for any excuse to pull the plug.
The consensus? Really? If so, then that just goes to show once again just how insane most people are. The organizers clearly were not looking for an excuse to pull the plug. The RD was literally (and I mean literally in the true definition of the word, not the modern perversion of it) crying while announcing the DQ. He clearly, obviously did not want to do it, but he felt that he had to enforce the rules as he saw it. Anyone who thinks otherwise is crazy.
It was an emotional moment, and one thing I think we can all agree on is that they made the decision too quickly. They should have taken more time to figure out what happened before ruling. But I think they were sleep-deprived and egged on by Laz's declaration that it was over followed by his exit. Most importantly, I think they were pressured by the psychological effect of having the infraction witnessed by thousands of live viewers.
There's a psychological effect illustrated by the example of drinking a bottle of alcohol in a paper bag. The fig-leaf of having the paper bag obscure the contents allows everyone involved--including authority figures--to have plausible deniability and choose to exercise discretion if they want to. People feel more obligated to enforce something if they know that others have seen that they have seen the infraction. If only one person observers the infraction, then they are much, much more likely to feel free to let it slide.
So because this infraction was observed live by thousands of people, the RDs felt an enormously greater amount of pressure to strictly enforce the rule than they would have felt if no one else but them had seen it. If this wasn't being streamed live, I bet the RDs wouldn't have DQed him. I think that's why the RD was crying. He didn't want to DQ Radek, but he felt forced to because too many people had witnessed the infraction and he didn't want anyone to accuse him of not enforcing the rules.