Dude there's no debate!
Tuohy is the goat of high school cross-country
And she's the goat of the 2019 High School cross country season
It's not even close
First of all she's the only top girl who's undefeated
Every other girl has lost at least once and most of them have lost twice
She also has clearly the highest speed ratings by big margin
She's averaging 165 and she has a 170 and two 168
All the other girls are in the low-to-mid 150s
She set the course record at Great American
And she swept through New York States and regionals which is the best Regional in the country by far with big-time performances
No one was within 20 seconds of her
None of the other girls are close they've all lost and they've all been in a bunch of close races and and had ratings 20 points below her
Speed ratings are super accurate. Tully knows what he's doing. They're usually within plus or minus one
Anyway it's a numbers game the girls had a full year of running to show where their numbers are at and she is clearly Victorious
I mean you can always make some cockamamie argument but facts are facts
She's undefeated, she has the highest speed rating, she has the course record at a prestigious National caliber meet Great American, and she won the National Championship which had the most elite runners in it