RunRagged wrote:
Most of us who need, or once needed, menstrual products don't care if a corporation removes the Venus symbol from its packaging. What concerns us is that the group spearheading this - girls and young women who identify as trans males and "masc enbies" - are deeply unhappy and full of absolute loathing, disgust and hatred for their own female bodies and biology and all that is associated with femaleness.
Many of these girls and young women have autism, ADD or are otherwise neuro-atypical; most have major other mental health problems (anorexia, anxiety, clinical depression, OCD); and most have histories of trauma, including a high frequency of childhood sex abuse. A significant proportion are same-sex attracted, but are so horrified at the thought of being lesbians that they identify as straight men. Weirdly, other young lesbians who've gone trans believe themselves to be gay men (see video below).
Whilst still in their teens, these girls and young women are being fast-tracked into taking cross-sex hormones that quickly have irreversible effects and are being encouraged to get double mastectomies as early as possible. In the US, girls are getting their breasts removed as young as 13, going on puberty blockers known to have terrible long-term effects (including an 8-9 point drop in IQ) as young as 8, starting testosterone at 13-14, and getting total hysterectomies as soon as they turn 18 - and in some cases, before.
In the UK, clinicians and physician trustees at the NHS gender clinic for children and adolescents have resigned because they believe the medical transing of young people is an unfolding health and medical-ethics scandal that in the future will be likened to the use of Thalidomide and lobotomies. They say transitioning kids and teens is the new anti-gay conversion therapy, a de facto method of "transing away the gay."
Many people who advocate and/or are caught up in transgenderism are deeply homophobic. For years now, lesbians have been harassed by "transbians" - het males who now say they are women - for not wanting to date or bed anyone with a "lady dick" and "brovaries." Just google the "cotton ceiling."
So far, girls and young women who identify as gay trans men have not been as aggressive towards gay guys, partly due to being raised and socialized as girls, their lack of sexual experience, and their fear of males. But now that huge numbers of girls and young women are "coming out" as gay men, this group is beginning to say that gay guys should be willing to have sex with them too. And that an unwillingness to do so is evidence that gay men are prejudiced "genital fetishists" full of hate for trans folx (sic).
Many young people into transness are now saying being same-sex attracted is inherently transphobic and wrong because "exclusionary." Indeed, they say that any sexual orientation other than pansexuality or omnisexuality is amoral because the doctrines of "acceptance without exception" and "total inclusivity" in all situations means everyone should be open to having sex with everyone else on the planet. In their view, all discretion equals discrimination and is therefore bad.
I wish it were true that the fad for medical transition is "not hurting anyone," as you say. But the stories of young people caught up in this cult are heartbreaking. See the accounts on reddit detrans (r/detrans), various detransitioning blogs, and the insightful YouTube videos of a young lesbian named Ben who explains here how/why for several years she believed she was a gay man:
https://youtu.be/hnkuEsGFcUYhttps://www.peaktrans.org/detransitioning/