Rdase wrote:
I get that it's your name but you're doing 5 workouts with minimal easy running. You're clearly talented enough to break 15 eventuallt, that tempo workout probably indicates sub 16 / sub 9 shape already. If you look at the vast majority of people who've broken 15, you'll find they
a) run 2-3 hard sessions a week, everything else easy
b) run pretty high volume (60-100 mpw)
When I ran 14:15 I'd do 1 tempo, 1 interval session around 5k-10k pace, strides once a week and around 75 miles / week. Easy runs would be around 7:00/mile.
Obviously if you're having good results and enjoying training I cant really criticize but all those hard sessions risks burnout and not doing enough mileage means you'll be aerobically underdeveloped.
Thanks very much for your feedback and for sharing your experiences! It is very good not just for me but for passive readers of the thread to hear from people who've 'been there and done it'!
I would be delighted if I am in sub 9 shape! It's the difficulty of converting treadmill pace to track pace that makes me wonder.
Yes, as you guessed, I'm aware that I'm not following the recommended training route; what you describe sounds like exactly what I think would be the recommended route to fast 5km running, and I cannot criticise it all!
Just in case it interests you or someone, I'll just offer a few thoughts on why I'm proceeding (for now at least!) a bit differently. This is absolutely not meant to be presumptious, or to indicate that I think that I know better!
1) My circumstances are such that I do not really have the opportunity to do that much easy running each week. At 7:00/mile, 75 miles per week would be 10-11 hours, and then there are the two workouts as well (or three if the strides are a separate session), which might be about 2 hours more. I just don't have that time available unfortunately. I have about 5-6 hours max available.
2) I do not really enjoy running 'easily'; I wouldn't really wish to run much below the aerobic threshold (about 70% of 5k pace, say). Maybe I could learn to enjoy it, but that's how I feel at the moment :-).
3) I make no claims to be any kind of expert, but I've tried to read and learn what I can, and I'm not convinced that high mileage is so important for the aerobic system for 5km or under, at least for someone with my background;
a) studies do seem to suggest that VO2Max and threshold runs are very effective in developing the aerobic system, if one is strong enough aerobically already to tolerate the work,
b) I have many years of cycling and other sport behind me, so I'd guess that, at least cardiovascularly, I have a decent base aerobic system; it is probably more of a case of specialising it towards running,
c) I think that the reason that it would not suit many people to more high quality work is that they would not recover in time and/or would not enjoy it; as you hint, I do actually enjoy my training and feel that it is rewarding, and for some reason I seem to recover reasonably quickly, or else I can tolerate some muscle soreness perhaps better than the average person!
d) All that said, I am very conscious of the possibility of losing aerobic fitness; I do an 'aerobic threshold' run every second week (latest yesterday!) of about 16km at a notch quicker than 4:00 min/km. I see that as a key workout to keep an eye on; as long as I can at least maintain my level (and ideally progress slowly) from one time to the next, I am not too worried, for if I can run using predominately my aerobic system, but the upper end of it, for 3-4 times the length of the races I'm training for, that should be enough aerobic support I think.
4) I'm 35, and may not have too many years ahead of me where I have a chance to run close to my potential. I'd kind of rather give it a full go and fail than die wondering :-).
I have a 3km race indoor in mid-January and again in mid-February. I'd love to run sub 9, and more generally do as well as I can, in one or both of those. I have then a 5km road race some time in April; if I could go sub 15 by then, that would be wonderful. After that my circumstances will change again, and I may not be able to train as often. Thus I'm planning to maintain my current schedule at least until January, and if the 3km races go well, maybe until the race in April. After that I'll take a step back and see whether I should change things; if things don't go well, I'll look into changing things earlier.
But in the meantime all feedback is very welcome; I read it and take it into consideration, even if I may not immediately act upon it.