I think he's nice guy and way faster than I'll ever be, but...he's looking for attention which is why he mentioned Letsrun. Jared, like 99% of elite runners surely read the forums and some surely post. Jared knows that comment will garner many responses.
I think the top Americans ran decent races. The fact is it was very fair weather and they were around 2:10 flat pace at halfway (not positive, but close to that) as I was tracking them on the ap. To slow down that much with 4 of them in close proximity is a bit surprising that not one ran around 2:10 flat. (I've run NY and understand the 2nd half of the race).
Rudy Chapa ran just over 2:11 for his debut marathon in the wet rain of 1983. Because of how the race unfolded with Dixon and Smith, Rudy wasn't even mentioned. Tabb and Tuttle were both 2:10 plus, weren't even mentioned.
How did they train so differently---Chapa, Tuttle, Tabb, etc...? If I were Ward, I'd be talking to them (yes I'm serious) to see what they did. Biwott, Derrick, Fauble, Ward...are all capable of 2:10 flat, but they ran 2.5 to 3 minutes slower.
They've got to figure it out.
For the record, I'm not ripping on any of them. I've met 3 of them and they were all super nice guys and obviously talented and hard working, but something is surely missing. I get it, some days you just don't have it, but eventually you've got to have a solid day to verify that you've been training right.