Couldn't disagree more--thank you for such an honest and insightful post, so glad you came out on the other side with close-call experience that not too many have. In any case, I doubt there is a single person here who thinks suicide is anything other than completely soul-crushing, whether you know the victim personally or not. There is certainly nothing in any way "romantic" about it at all.
That being said, the point that is being dissected in terms of "romanticizing" or "glorifying" the act is that maybe, just maybe, some struggling kid (or adult) who doesn't feel heard or seen or understood or enough or as though anybody cares and is questioning if it's worth going on and is desperate for an escape from things they can't cope with, might read something like this and think, "Well, there's a way to get everybody to notice and finally care about what I'm going through." So perhaps from their perspective, it ends up being "romanticized" in that sense and in a way is the proverbial straw that breaks the camel's back. I don't personally see it that way, thankfully most people probably don't, but somebody might. I don't know if that makes sense.
There is a song lyric, I don't recall from where, that's says, "Funny when you're dead how people start listening." The bottom line is that above all else, hopefully Madison's story will end up shedding more light on ways to combat the fact that, in today's world, that is sometimes the heartbreaking reality, and it shouldn't be at all.