agip wrote:
I can't follow your double negatives.
I'm not sure what Nadler and Lieu said so I have no comment on them.
The bottom line is that Ted Lieu got Mueller to agree that had Trump not been President that he would have been indicted.
Ted Lieu/Mueller exchange:
“I’d like to ask you the reason, again, that you did not indict Donald Trump is because of OLC [Office of Legal Counsel] opinion stating that you cannot indict a sitting president, correct?” Rep. Ted Lieu (D-CA) asked Mueller.
Mueller’s response was straightforward: “That is correct.”
Later in the day, Mueller thought better of that answer and stated:
“I want to go back to one thing that was said this morning by Mr. Lieu who said, and I quote, ‘you didn’t charge the president because of the OLC opinion.’ That is not the correct way to say it,” Mueller said in his statement. “As we say in the report and as I said at the opening, we did not reach a determination as to whether the president committed a crime.”
Later, in an interview with Jake Tapper, Nadler referred to the former exchange between Lieu and Mueller, and Tapper excoriated him for it. That is CNN's Jake Tapper for those Trumpers who don't believe any fairness comes out of CNN.
So...what's the takeaway:
1) Ted Lieu CORRECTLY laid out the three criteria that needed to be met to determine Obstruction of Justice.
2) Ted Lieu then went a step further and tried to get Mueller to agree that if not for the OLC opinion that Trump would have been indicted. Mueller initially agreed with that and then later said that wasn't the right way to say it.
3) Nadler was either being disingenuous or was ill-prepared (probably the former) when talking to Jake Tapper.
So...
1) Nadler was wrong. A hit to his integrity.
2) Ted Lieu wasn't wrong because he was asking a question/asking for clarity of/from Mueller.
3) Mueller gave an answer to Lieu that he later regretted and so he rightfully corrected his statement later. This correction was in keeping with his attitude in the report and his reported penchant for adhering to rules and laws. He clearly punted to Congress in the report, and he was not about to be taken down a road he didn't want to travel.