Shannon Rowbury fires shots at Caster Semenya

The joke is on us wrote:

Shannon moved up to my #1 favorite current pro, calling it like it is, helping to protect girls and women everywhere

Now let's see more women speak up against this travesty.

CWRP wrote:

Semenya is probably a legitimately rare case of XX with some XY biology.

Semenya was born a guy, and he is a guy.

Chilhowee wrote:

Now that caster ( who lacks a uterus, apparently) is off the testosterone reducing medication, /he knows, she feels the difference, the increase in her power. /he is a thief, a liar, when /he claims it is just fitness. You also, are a liar, an enemy of not only of sport, but of ethics, when you criticize rowbury's legitimate reaction to the cas's absurd judgement.

kjsdeglsG wrote:

^Thank you! I had the same thought.

Nominally Ivy League-educated white men can't even recognize their systematic use of racist while-on-black violence language.

Just eliminate womens events all together and make them compete with the men.

Actually Caster has NO ovaries. No womb, no uterus. If you knew what yoy were talking about yoy'd know that this is a man with androgen insensitivity and insensitivity unless it is complete still affects them. Her phenotypes are almost completely male. Along with her levels this was a no brainer. Her records and wins hopefully will be expunged once this gets overturned again and this farce can be squashed. Caster Semenya should never have been allowed to compete on the professional level. As am amateur fine. Not like this. But know wtf youre talking about first

speak up and be more direct man!

That aside Rowbury comes off as a little snarky in general - not really a likeable person and "women have fought etc" was a stupid comment and had nothing to do with anything.

That being said it is pretty clear Semenya has a big advantage - seems like it would be pretty simple to just implement some sort of hormone testing standard so IAAF could even the field and not discriminate.

Jamin, I seriously think you should get a sex change! That way you can compete in a women's/intersex race with your 1:57? 800 and probably win a medal! Take the plunge, man! You're bottomed out as a guy. and it'll only get worse when you get older. You'll get laid by strapping young bi guys but you will get laid. I think it'd be a big win for you and get you out of your dating and mating rut in a big way. Plus, you could win a medal and be a real American hero next to Caitlyn J. Think of the adulation you'd receive.

jamin wrote:

Typical liberal double-talk. lol

Libs love to corrupt the word "right(s)."

dadude wrote:

Just eliminate womens events all together and make them compete with the men.

Require that all the men, trannys, homos, gender confused people and anyone else not born a woman either compete in the open (men's) events, or go home.

I do run run run wrote:

Actually Caster has NO ovaries. No womb, no uterus. If you knew what yoy were talking about yoy'd know that this is a man with androgen insensitivity and insensitivity unless it is complete still affects them. Her phenotypes are almost completely male. Along with her levels this was a no brainer. Her records and wins hopefully will be expunged once this gets overturned again and this farce can be squashed. Caster Semenya should never have been allowed to compete on the professional level. As am amateur fine. Not like this. But know wtf youre talking about first

Well said. Thank you

There is NO EVIDENCE WHATSOEVER that Caster has a vagina. Show us the evidence if you disagree.

Even if you pass a visual test for man boobs that doesn\'t make you a woman.

Caster is a man. Anyone can see that. He probably has a malformed or underdeveloped penis. The mosaic making up the gender specific parts of Caster is at least 95% male and 5% female. He is a man. Nothing else than a man. He can identify as a female as much as he wish. But he has no business stealing medals from women.

People who has 46XY usually are born with undeveloped or ambiguous external genitals. XY is male. If a penis doe snot develop, it looks like a vagina. Both structures are homologous: they develop from the same basic substrates in the organism. That is why a person with 46XY can have internal testis, male hormones, male chromosomes and a male physique, but with genitals that looks like a women's from the outside. Caster is 46 XY dsd. Biologically women do not have Y chromsones, only men. But because Caster looked like a girl from the outside when born (due to 46XY) she was legally registered and raised as a women, so even though her sex is more male, her gender identity is female.

People who has 46XY usually are born with undeveloped or ambiguous external genitals. XY is male. If a penis doe snot develop, it looks like a vagina. Both structures are homologous: they develop from the same basic substrates in the organism. That is why a person with 46XY can have internal testis, male hormones, male chromosomes and a male physique, but with genitals that looks like a women's from the outside. Caster is 46 XY dsd. Biologically women do not have Y chromosomes, only men. But because Caster looked like a girl from the outside when born (due to 46XY) she was legally registered and raised as a women, so even though her sex is more male, her gender identity is female.

Why has a 3 YO thread be revived.