There is no evidence presented in a readable format. No, I'm sorry, 8000+ posts on letsrun are not evidence. Neither are a huge google doc or a complex web site.
Present evidence as 3-4 obviously faked "runs" and explain why they're fake. Compare the paces to world records or similar. Unless a short list of clear evidence is presented, expect the "independent" analyzers to conclude there's no evidence for him cheating. For example they may say:
1) GPS data: We have investigated all the presented Strava data and have not found any legs that would be impossible for RY to run. The paces are fast, but with a 2:41 marathon PR he would be capable of running every one of these legs. His recovery is remarkable as has been proven by a team of scientists and in particular by his win in the RaceAcrossUSA race (where he even added a fast marathon in London). Although the GPS data is not complete there is no evidence that RY has cheated.
2) Video proof: Allegations of cheating have been raised after stealth filming and a video obtained from a surveillance camera. The claims were that RY did not run but rode in the RV. We have compared the GPS data and the video from the surveillance camera. It is clear that RY walks by the surveillance camera exactly like the the GPS data predicts. The allegation of cheating is obviously false.
The "stealth video" was shot by a runner who claims he wanted to run with RY. The video does not show RY, but that does not prove cheating. A group of observers admitted it was extremely difficult to spot RY as he would often run on the other side of the road. They had to invent special techniques to spot him (looking for his feet under the RV). That the runner who didn't even present himself to the team failed to film RY does not constitute evidence of cheating. It should be kept in mind that it was this same runner who raised the false allegation that RY didn't pass the surveillance camera.
3) A group of independent observers (highly experienced multi day runners) followed RY for several days. They could not report any kind of cheating.
Conclusion: There is neither GPS evidence, video evidence or evidence from witnesses that RY has cheated. As there are gaps in the GPS data, they cannot be used as evidence for a record run. However, this point is moot as RY got injured and did not complete the record attempt. He does not intend to seek the Guinness world record for the fastest run across the USA.
Comment from SKINS: It should be noted that RY agrees that the data collection was not good enough despite the hard efforts of the whole team. They are now looking into better methods for data gathering. We are certain that they will fine tune these minor issues and we look forward to sponsoring Rob's next adventure.