---

ThunderThighs wrote:

getting wrong wrote:

writer of bad comments wrote:

rules is rules wrote:
Can I suggest that for every person who has written a bad comment that you pledge to donate $1.00 if Rob succeeds in this challenge and to double it if he is proven to have done it without cheating.

---

I'll pledge to donate $1.00 for his data regardless of whether he succeeds or has cheated.

Deal?

^^^^
This, the comments in here are becoming disgusting, his childhood or personal life/past have nothing to do with his sporting claims or achievements.

I haven't made any comments about his childhood or personal life but I completely disagree with you saying that it has nothing to do with what is happening here. The guy parades his childhood and past out for interviews and his book for Christ's sake. He makes money and publicity glorifying his childhood, past, and family. It is completely appropriate to question his about such things because, I bet you, a lot of it is going to be another lie.

---

He will do it wrote:
He can save about 5 miles going to Atlantic City instead of NYC. Not worth the trade off

---

---

larkimm wrote:
Do we know that the 1980 record wasn't faked? Where are his GPS trace files...?

---

---

Brianruns10 wrote:
I'd imagine there are those of you who have had similar experiences, but I don't think RY's personality is unique by any stretch among runners. I knew just such a runner.

Several years ago, I met a runner whom we'll call Jason, following a 10K that a ran, in which he also participated (finishing behind me). He was friendly enough and talked about his training and his aspirations in the marathon. At the time I had similar aspirations and so we went for a few runs together.

I quickly discovered not all was right. That outgoing, friendly personality revealed a narcissism that impressive in its scope. All conversations inevitably returned to him and how he was going to quality for the OT marathon later that year, how he was going to make the World's team.

But his actual ability didn't seem to gel with his aspirations. He struggled to keep up on a six mile run, despite claiming to be running two a days, and logging elite level weekly mileage. He had a poor running form, almost knocking knees and pronating to the point that I wondered if he'd even been fitted for a proper set of trainers.

I eventually stopped running with him, but he would occasionally turn up at group runs with the local sub-elite outfit. By now, his character took on a new angle, as his bluster turned to outright exagerration and falsehood. He claimed Powerbar was sponsoring him, when in fact he was just getting free samples that Powerbar gives to anyone who claims to be a coach or trainer. He claimed outrageous times that he couldn't back up, such as having broken 15 minutes for 5K on a track.

At area races, he consistently underperformed, running 19 minute 5Ks, and always he had an excuse...he took a wrong turn, he tripped. His favorite excuse was that he was using the race as a training/tempo run. Over the course of a summer he managed to alienate the entire running community by claiming his superiority in racing. Several challenged him to races, offering to comp his entry fee. He never accepted, but continued to claim he was the best, without any proof.

Eventually he lost every shred of credibility he had. He was a decent runner, but could find no one to run with because everyone was so thoroughly tired of him.

I think RY is the same type of personality. He's a narcissist in search of a source to validate that narcissism. He has made increasingly outrageous claims that don't seem to be backed up by anything, and now finally the wall he has built up around himself is starting to come down as more people call him on it and challenge him to prove his mettle.

I feel very sorry for him.

---

---

sasquatch wrote:

Patience and planning wrote:
I think pretty much everyone on this thread would be willing to donate $1 if Rob succeeds, and $1,000,000 if he can prove he didn't cheat.

---

Not me.

a. unlike everyone else on this board, I don't actually have $1,000,000.

b. I'm pretty sure he cheated, but not $1,000,000 sure.

---

team1.kml wrote:
There are many inconsistencies, but a few here have focused on the May 18 day in which the RV got stuck in the sand. I'm not sure if you saw these graphics that summarize some of what we know about that day:(http://imgur.com/zjXpAoP) and this one (http://i.imgur.com/HdyOwyd.jpg). They need some more updates because we have deduced more since those were made.

---

---

Paula's husband wrote:
I will donate the million pounds my wife saved by not taking the lie detector test she promised.

sasquatch wrote:

Patience and planning wrote:
I think pretty much everyone on this thread would be willing to donate $1 if Rob succeeds, and $1,000,000 if he can prove he didn't cheat.

---

Not me.

a. unlike everyone else on this board, I don't actually have $1,000,000.

b. I'm pretty sure he cheated, but not $1,000,000 sure.

---

RvaRunner wrote:
One of the reasons this message board can suck at times...People who have never attempted to do any "Multi-day events" chiming in with how easy it is. We saw it last year with the Jurek thread about the AT record and now have seen it with this thread.

I get it. Everyone on this damn site does 100+mpw at 2:15 marathon pace, so of course doing 50 miles per day is easy, given you have 24 hours to do it. I mean, come one, that's barely under 30 minute per mile pace!

The reality is that doing 50 miles PER DAY, EVERYDAY for 45 (PLUS) DAYS IN A ROW is hard as hell. That is doing 350 Mile weeks every week for the better part of 7 straight weeks Add in elevation, weather, etc and it makes for one hell of a challenge.

Look I don't know if he cheated. Based upon the evidence presented on this board, I would lean towards yes, he was, before Asher called him out.

---

---

my pedometer says so wrote:
I walk 10,000 steps a day, which is close to 50 miles. I won my office walk challenge, and even beat the fat lady from HR.

RvaRunner wrote:
One of the reasons this message board can suck at times...People who have never attempted to do any "Multi-day events" chiming in with how easy it is. We saw it last year with the Jurek thread about the AT record and now have seen it with this thread.

I get it. Everyone on this damn site does 100+mpw at 2:15 marathon pace, so of course doing 50 miles per day is easy, given you have 24 hours to do it. I mean, come one, that's barely under 30 minute per mile pace!

The reality is that doing 50 miles PER DAY, EVERYDAY for 45 (PLUS) DAYS IN A ROW is hard as hell. That is doing 350 Mile weeks every week for the better part of 7 straight weeks Add in elevation, weather, etc and it makes for one hell of a challenge.

Look I don't know if he cheated. Based upon the evidence presented on this board, I would lean towards yes, he was, before Asher called him out.

---

---

A lie why? Because you believe it to be.

Bunch of deluded odd people on here

---

---

Brianruns10 wrote:
I'd imagine there are those of you who have had similar experiences, but I don't think RY's personality is unique by any stretch among runners. I knew just such a runner.

Several years ago, I met a runner whom we'll call Jason, following a 10K that a ran, in which he also participated (finishing behind me). He was friendly enough and talked about his training and his aspirations in the marathon. At the time I had similar aspirations and so we went for a few runs together.

I quickly discovered not all was right. That outgoing, friendly personality revealed a narcissism that impressive in its scope. All conversations inevitably returned to him and how he was going to quality for the OT marathon later that year, how he was going to make the World's team.

But his actual ability didn't seem to gel with his aspirations. He struggled to keep up on a six mile run, despite claiming to be running two a days, and logging elite level weekly mileage. He had a poor running form, almost knocking knees and pronating to the point that I wondered if he'd even been fitted for a proper set of trainers.

I eventually stopped running with him, but he would occasionally turn up at group runs with the local sub-elite outfit. By now, his character took on a new angle, as his bluster turned to outright exagerration and falsehood. He claimed Powerbar was sponsoring him, when in fact he was just getting free samples that Powerbar gives to anyone who claims to be a coach or trainer. He claimed outrageous times that he couldn't back up, such as having broken 15 minutes for 5K on a track.

At area races, he consistently underperformed, running 19 minute 5Ks, and always he had an excuse...he took a wrong turn, he tripped. His favorite excuse was that he was using the race as a training/tempo run. Over the course of a summer he managed to alienate the entire running community by claiming his superiority in racing. Several challenged him to races, offering to comp his entry fee. He never accepted, but continued to claim he was the best, without any proof.

Eventually he lost every shred of credibility he had. He was a decent runner, but could find no one to run with because everyone was so thoroughly tired of him.

I think RY is the same type of personality. He's a narcissist in search of a source to validate that narcissism. He has made increasingly outrageous claims that don't seem to be backed up by anything, and now finally the wall he has built up around himself is starting to come down as more people call him on it and challenge him to prove his mettle.

I feel very sorry for him.

---

---

JB1983 wrote:

ThunderThighs wrote:

A lie why? Because you believe it to be.

Bunch of deluded odd people on here

---

Rob Young has lied or greatly exaggerated about everything else so it is only logically to question what he has publicly published and said in interviews about his childhood/personal life.

You have no idea if he has lied or not yet

your name would be better suited as ThunderCvnt

---

ICE wrote:
Does the Limey have a work visa?

---

---

letsbang wrote:
Like wtf dude, your times can be verified online, this isn't the 1960's.

---

---

Brianruns10 wrote:
I'd imagine there are those of you who have had similar experiences, but I don't think RY's personality is unique by any stretch among runners. I knew just such a runner.

Several years ago, I met a runner whom we'll call Jason, following a 10K that a ran, in which he also participated (finishing behind me). [snip]

---

---

Henry Spencer wrote:

doubler wrote:
I hope to be out there to meet up with the caravan either tomorrow or Sunday night/Monday morning.

The timing of when he'll be right in my backyard couldn't be worse. I will be up North in Cleveland over the weekend. I suspect he'll hit the Dayton area Saturday/Sunday.

---

Great. Perhaps then you will have some actual original material that you can add to your blog rather than copying it from other forums, articles, or blogs.

---

doubler wrote:

Henry Spencer wrote:

doubler wrote:
I hope to be out there to meet up with the caravan either tomorrow or Sunday night/Monday morning.

The timing of when he'll be right in my backyard couldn't be worse. I will be up North in Cleveland over the weekend. I suspect he'll hit the Dayton area Saturday/Sunday.

---

Great. Perhaps then you will have some actual original material that you can add to your blog rather than copying it from other forums, articles, or blogs.

Please find an article on my blog where I copied from other forums.

There was the long Parvaneh thread, other than that, I believe I was the first to write anything about the rest of the cases. And there was plenty of new evidence presented in those articles.

---

sub-14 guy wrote:

letsbang wrote:
Like wtf dude, your times can be verified online, this isn't the 1960's.

---

That's why I only talk about my running anonymously on letsrun.