I'd like to know what Greg McMillan and John Kellogg think.
I think it's fine that Underwood is trying to "catch people who use those cheating drugs." That's great. I also completely agree with his findings--as my comments above suggest--about the deleterious effects of binge drinking. Back in 2008, that's what he was working on.
http://www.malmstrom.af.mil/news/story.asp?id=123093688
"If you binge drink regularly," he said, "you become someone who operates at a fraction of your potential."
What's not to like about that research? That makes sense.
When you start arguing that even a single beer or a single glass of wine, or a single shot, sets you back a full week's training--well, that's what I call fundamentalism. The truth rarely lies with fundamentalisms.