Some ideas from an athlete I helped find a school recently - if you stay around the times you posted, you kinda have three choices:
1. Be the slowest guy on super fast D1 team - you won't make the travel team unless you improve a lot (you might race a lot in local meets against D2/3 competition), you will get your #$%& kicked in practice every day, and if you don't improve you may lose your spot to next year's recruits. Also, at the fast D1 schools they essentially own you - school will be more about running than school. But you will likely run the fastest you can run. Some thrive in this, others don't. One example: Miami of Ohio - Beautiful school, great Mid-D program but they have 4 guys under 1:50 I believe, so you'll need to improve substantially just to make the bigger meets.
2. Go to a middle of the road D1 - you'll be on the travel squad and compete in the big meets, where you will get crushed by the guys from the fast schools unless you improve a lot. No real shot at competing for team championships since Oregon etc. will win them all. One example: UVM - academically great school, you'd be in the sweet spot as far as times. Downsides: not much financial aid for Out of State students and they are unlikely to win much given their conference and their level of commitment.
3. Go D2/D3 - you'll be very important to the team from the very first day, and you'll get to help compete for team championships (although they are lower division), which is fun. Downside is you will have less competition day to day in practice so you may not improve quite as much. You also have more time to enjoy other activities in college, which can be a big deal to a lot of people. One example: St Lawrence - D3, not for everyone because it is isolated, but if you like the outdoors and want to compete for championships they have a great running tradition, great coaching and amazing athletic facilities. Ithaca is a similar option but we preferred SLU, Allegheny (great financial aid), Denison.
The kid I was working with eventually chose the high level D3 option and is really enjoying himself, but it was a close call between that and being the tail on the high level D1 dog. Option 2 (where a lot of the schools you listed are) was less appealing - most of the Mid level D1's are no faster than his D3, and some are quite a bit slower.
YMMV though.