I personally love super smash bros. it should be listed in the top 5 of fighting games bc it was so revolutionary.
for the super Mario galaxy 2 vote. in a way you're right and it may be the most crisp mario game. the problem is it's been made so recently. I give a nod to older games that redefined what was possible with gaming. galaxy was crazy fun and beautiful but I'd expect that from a great recent Mario game with wiis power. Think about it, Tetris is rated really highly by most people. obviously there are better games in herbs of gameplay, strategy, graphics, south,etc but you have to consider its cultural impact, how good it was for the time, etc.
I bleeping loved brood war. use map settings rocked.
Great choices people! let's make this a bit easier. top 3 games and systems.
games: oot, 007, super Mario 3
systems: n64, wii, ps2
I have a nod to revolutionary systems and it's hard to argue with what n64 did fo multiplayer and what wii did for gameplay mechanics. ps2 had so many good games it was just silly.