Mr Goododds wrote:
What has he really done? 3:46 AR okay, but medals?
Medals aren't givens, even for a 3:30/3:46 guy.
Sure, Webb showed unprecedented (for the US) potential in high school with the 3:53 mile at Pre and the 3:38 at USAs. He was seen as the biggest hope talent-wise that the US had against the equally-precocious Kenyans and the other top 1,500 runners of the world.
But think about that "equally precocious" part - everybody's always talking about some new Kenyan who runs 3:32 or better at age 17 or 18 (alright, maybe not all of them are 17 or 18, but they're new faces to deal with nonetheless). Assuming even a few of these guys really are 18 - heck, even if they're 22 - that represents a few other Webbs out there who will be in the picture for the next several years. In other words, he's not alone in talent. Plus he has to race the best from Europe along with the resurgent New Zealand 1,500 guys. Then there are the dopers - Ramzi (2012? I can only hope not), I'm looking in your direction.
Running 3:30/3:46 and placing 9th and 8th at WCs these days is actually accomplishing a lot, even for a guy who ran 3:53 in high school, considering the other talent (and some drugs) out there. There are other guys with even more ability than Webb and still others who are more experienced and better international racers than Webb. You have to do so much right and even get a little lucky sometimes to get a medal, even if you can run fast times and/or beat many of the other contenders in non-championship races.
In some sense, Webb has "failed" to realize his potential, and his career has obviously been incredibly checkered. And he's done some stupid things in both training and racing (e.g., trying to steal the race by sprinting with 700 left at Worlds - that worked at USAs, but these guys were much better and they rolled him up less than 300 later). But his whole career, he's always just been trying to make stuff happen, even if it has been in unconventional ways. He's a "get it now" guy, which is often a great attribute for bringing out talent early in a career but can be a curse when racing the most experienced (and equally-talented) runners in the world. Of course, he's been regarded so far by the critics who aren't in the arena as "underachieving" or as "a flop on the big stage." But when we look at who's he's up against, we can't say he's been a 100% failure.
Let's just say he's had his moments of greatness but frustratingly can't seem to summon them very often.