^^^^^Ignore that^^^^^^it came from my form filling program.
Anyhow to answer a few questions: First Dee, I am in NH and went to Dr. McCarthy at Newton-Wellesley. Your symptoms all sound like symptoms of a labral tear. You probably want to go to a doctor in Boston or at a major hospital that has done lots of these. If yours came from a fall, then there is probably no FAI. I read that Dr. McCarthy does not do FAI, but I could be wrong. Someone else mentioned Dr. Busconi, I called his office and he wouldn't see me as I was over 50. I had my surgery 1 1/2 years ago and got back to running quickly, but still am trying to overcome the nasty compensations I had developed running with the bad hip over the years. I did 71 miles last week just to see if I could and because things are still getting better with the compensations as I try to recover my stride.
Dan P 8, I had the labral tear surgery with no FAI. I am not sure if Dr. McCarthy treats or believes in FAI. I may be wrong, but it is something I read awhile back. Maybe that is why he doesn't want to do the surgery. Ask around at other doctors. I hear some of the big docs: Philippon, Byrd, Kelly will read your MRIs for you for free if you send them to them. I didn't do this, but I keep hearing that many people do.
I have tried just about everything pre and post surgery to fix my running stride from the compensations I had developed. One key thing I found was Muscle Activation Technique (M.A.T.) I did about 10 sessions in the fall and it worked to help find inhibited muscles throughout my body and got them working and firing again. My running is slowly coming along and I am told my stride is so much better. I am still trying to get rid of a pinch in my hip adductors and find some speed in my running.