For once, the truth wrote:
Again, the gratuitous nastiness. Yes, it's The New Yorker. No, I'm not going to give you my name now -- that's irrelevant, what's relevant is the actual story -- so please give up that silly little guessing game, everyone.
I'm extremely dubious given the history of this thread and I have never attached much importance to the holy writ of an article, time will tell. However you are entirely correct in your condemnation of much of what has been said. I don't bear Kip any ill-will, I'll never meet him. As others have said a full and frank public admission that could not possibly have been faked would have closed this matter over a year ago. Its never the misdeed that is the real problem, its the denials and cover-ups which insult people's intelligence that is the real issue.