I'm surprised no one has mentioned Andy Powell or Franklin Sanchez, two of the Massachusetts high school phenom's of the 90's.
Andy Powell
800 - 1:51
Mile - 4:02
2 Mile - 8:49 (Indoor vs Sanchez)
5k XC - 14:52 (Franklin Park in Boston)
Franklyn Sanchez
800 - 1:55
Mile - 4:08
2 Mile - 8:47 (Indoor vs Powell)
5k - couldn't find any results but at the State XC meet in 1998 Sanchez ran 14:01 to Powell's 14:00 on a 2.9 mile course
* Sanchez also set the US JR record in the 5k in 2000, running 13:38.39
Here's that 8:47/8:49 race indoors