Calling a Kettle Black wrote:
Good point, you've obviously spent enough time with her, know her work discipline, understand her biomechanics and talent to form such an enlightened opinion.
Cook gave her a frank assessment based on experience you dont have. He might be wrong, but he might be realistic and wanted her to focus on a closer goal that he thought she could better achieve.
F that.
When I got to college, I was a 33:00 10k guy. My goal was to break 30:00 by the time I graduated. But I was realistic and didn't start doing 30:00 workouts right away. I ran 32:30. They sub-32:00. Then 31:30. And so on. Finally, after four years of hard work, at Penn my senior year I ran 29:45.
I guess Cook would've pegged me for a 29:45 guy right off the bat, but most people wouldn't. It's hard to tell when someone has hit a plateau or if they can still get faster. Erin probably knows she won't run 4:00 today, but she will work on the steps to reach that goal.
We should send Cook around to every athlete so he can tell them exactly what their best time will be. In fact, let's stop racing all together and just have Cook score every meet since he knows exactly where everyone will finish!