Vince Neil of Motley Crue vs. Axl Rose of Guns n' Roses and Van Halen vs. AC/DC

1. G N R has some incredible songs.

2. AC/DC also has great songs.

3. VH was extremely talented but too poppy or weird.

4. Motley Crue I don't know so well.

I think this song from Motley Crue is kind of fun. I like Vince Neil's voice in it:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6nm1BJPe-pg

(Wild Side)

You've got me captured. I'm under your spell. I guess I'll never learn.

AC/DCis worst band ever. Bret michaels and Poison best group ever.

Camoo wrote:

Vince Neil and Axl have both had plastic surgery. That doesn't seem like a very "rock 'n' roll" thing to do, at least it didn't used to be.

They DID NOT have plastic surgery, they were REPLACED! It is amazing they get away with it but MANY bands from the 60's, 70's and 80's are now TRIBUTE BANDS! Look at videos from the early 80's till now and Vince and Axle are TOTALLY DIFFERENT PEOPLE! Same with Jon Bon Jovi, Bono, Sting, Eddie Van Halen etc. etc. I think some of these guys retire but of course in the case of Motley Crue NOBODY could have done what they did and lived! Check out the "Doppelganger and Identity Research Society" website to learn more.

Kopernicus wrote:

AC/DCis worst band ever.

They are certainly the most overrated rock band ever. They appeal Classic Rock diehard wannabees. It's "cool" to like AC/DC.

Granted: Maybe I don't get them. Maybe there's something I'm missing in what sounds to me like simple, generic, bland music and lyrics.

Guns n' Roses!

Even though I was to young at the height of these bands...

I'm a huge fan ..

I love motley crue.. though it's TRUE, they only have like 2 good songs per album... but the songs that are good? Are fucking awesome!

I love GNR .. appitite and illusions are incredible,

I love the whole group..but slash? WOW!

I wish axle wasn't such a prick cuz I think GNR could have been greater for longer if they could have gotten past the drama.

ACDC.. just a hit song factory... I love the vibe and sound of acdc.... both bon Scott and Brian Johnson are/were incredible.

Van Halen? I really wish I knew this band better. after reading all your guys reviews, I realise they're a band I need to listen to and learn about.

mr_E_dice-8ighty6ix wrote:

Even though I was to young at the height of these bands...

I'm a huge fan ..

I love motley crue.. though it's TRUE, they only have like 2 good songs per album... but the songs that are good? Are fucking awesome!

I love GNR .. appitite and illusions are incredible,

I love the whole group..but slash? WOW!

I wish axle wasn't such a prick cuz I think GNR could have been greater for longer if they could have gotten past the drama.

ACDC.. just a hit song factory... I love the vibe and sound of acdc.... both bon Scott and Brian Johnson are/were incredible.

Van Halen? I really wish I knew this band better. after reading all your guys reviews, I realise they're a band I need to listen to and learn about.

I'm very much a Van Halen fan. Don't bother with the Sammy albums. DLR had the right style for VH and his vocals were perfected in the studio. Sammy was cool with Montrose in the early '70s, but had lost his way by the time he joined VH.

Bon Scott

2. ac/dc Brian Johnson

3. AC/DC

4. Van Halen

5. Ac/Dc

6.Motley Crue

7.Guns N Roses

People tend to like the music they listened to during their teenage years. I was 14 when Back in Black came out and I had a copy on 8-track. Best album ever! Or so I thought.... It's still good.