seven costanza wrote:
kitchybigs wrote:
It’s not cheating because literally EVERY school has the opportunity to do what BYU does.
Sure okay. Is drug-dealing ethical because everyone has the "opportunity" to become a drug dealer??
Every school could do what BYU does... but they don't. Note the difference in ethics and values. BYU found a "loophole" and exploited it. Scummy, shady stuff.
The silver lining, I guess, is that with a team of 28 year olds all these dudes are at their peak in college. Never seen a BYU grandpa do squat on the world scene.
Sorry, these are all tired arguments.
"Every school could do what BYU does... but they don't".
This is true. Every school could recruit these BYU guys, too. There are plenty of coaches in various sports that lose interest in athletes that express plans to go on a mission. There are also plenty of promising athletes that don't become great after a mission. It's not a given that they're at an advantage. It's also not unheard of for sports teams to create a bit of an age advantage in college outside of BYU. One example--Penn State's wrestling program often redshirts/grayshirts freshmen, so they have guys winning national championships that are 24+ years old sometimes.
"team of 28 year olds"
I know you're exaggerating, but this is false. Mantz can't be older than 24, tops. Sure that's a little older than a 5th year senior in the spring. But, he also took two years completely off of running, and has come back from multiple injuries in the last year to year and a half. He's a stud and ran an excellent race. There are also often guys on the team that aren't at an "age advantage." Garnica didn't go on a mission, Clinger and Troutner got back from missions in the last year or so (i.e. they have two years less training than guys their age from other schools at this very moment). Guys from the past like Rory Linkletter and pretty sure Connor McMillan didn't go on missions. Mantz has been great for a few seasons when he didn't have an "age advantage".
"Never seen a BYU grandpa do squat on the world scene"
I don't know what your definition of the world scene is, but this could be said for basically any college in America if we're looking at medals in Olympics, world championships, major marathons, etc.
If you have a looser definition of world scene (i.e. top notch US runners), ever heard of Jared Ward, Connor McMillan, Josh McCown, Ed Eyestone, or Doug Padilla? If I'm using Connor McMillan, I also better include Linkletter who also has run 2:12 in the marathon.
Anyway, this argument distracts from the fact that Eyestone is a brilliant coach. There's no denying that. I'm willing to guess that Eyestone would have success at pretty much any school. That's not to mention that he's probably working with a smaller pool of recruits than schools like Stanford, Colorado, NAU, etc. since he needs to bring in runners that are interested in attending BYU.