Times are changin wrote:
Sure you did. D2 and weak D1 schools are underfunded which is why they are slow. Your offers woukd have been about the same there as at a solid D1. What D3 school provided a totally free education to your friend? I have had many smart runners who were also very fast. They took the best offer they could get regardless of Division or tier. It almost always was on of out instate public schools. No D3 came close to full even for a 36 ACT.
What I said happened. Not just to me and my friend. That's how the market worked.
As to your claim that such offers as I had would be about the same as at a solid D1 school, that is a very general remark, and is not true to my recollection, but maybe what you said would be true nowadays.
I went to one of the best Div 1 track programs. I would not have wasted my time at anything else. Just had bad luck that the great asst coach was fired shortly before I matriculated, and to add insult to injury the admin hired the least qualified applicant because he accepted the lowest offer. He did get fired after 2 years, but that coach had an adverse impact on the track athletes, not just me.
When I didn't go to Oregon as a walk-on after the 1st year of college was when I made my mistake. I repeatedly thought about going, and my HS coach had trained 1 year CC at Oregon with Dellinger and Bowerman when my coach was a grad student. He would have called Dellinger about me. Instead I worked full-time for a year, and that made it very difficult on myself to race fast after that, but I almost did succeed (I got injured.) Well, I got injured because I decided to run a half-marathon in the morning into school, as it was 13 miles from the house where I and some runners were renting rooms. In fact, a fellow runner who had a car offered to drop me off 5 miles from school and I declined, so there was no good reason for my long run. Moreover, it was road or cement all the way in, and that was not good. The final straw was that afternoon I ran 10 x 200m in 26+ (on the fly). The next day the lateral-collateral on my right leg swelled and I could hardly walk. A few days later the new technology of running electricity through the nerves was applied. The recovery took most of the summer, and the new coach wasn't interested...I could barely break 2 min in August, and although I would have been under 1:55 by December (so as to run 1:50-52 by April), I had become excess baggage and he had elite recruits (including from overseas) who were in their prime, much like I was when I left HS.
After college, middle distance races and opportunities to train with elite runners dry up unless one is international class.
That your friends took the best offer they could get is based on their values. My values were to go to one of the best programs, and those athletes without sports that year almost disappeared from coaches' recruiting radars. My HS coach had to call coaches, trying to convince them to come and watch me run in an open meet, when most of the coaches just went to the state meets and made offers there.
I can understand your friends' perspective if this was recent decision-making, because the costs of college as a percentage of the median or average income has increased so dramatically that it would be hard nowadays to turn down such an offer, and I probably would not.
I am not saying that the costs of IV league type schools has increased at the same rate as most of the schools, as their costs were always high as a percentage of median or average incomes.