Brittle Master 1958 wrote:
borders wrote:
Unfortunately colonizers carving the continent up during the last couple centuries into "countries" with little regard to existing ethnic, cultural, and political dynamics has only blown this up.
This point has been over-emphasized.
Do you think African tribes were living in prosperous peace and harmony before colonizers showed up?
I majored in poli sci back in the day, and in my international development course, I learned that the most stable Third World countries were generally the ones that had been colonized by the British and had a set of reasonably stable institutions imposed on them.
In other words, the countries that had been most thoroughly colonized for the longest period of time, were doing the best in the modern world. Other countries that were doing their own thing tended to do less well.
I'm not necessarily saying you're wrong, but I just wanted to point out that learning something in a Western poli sci course doesn't make it fact.... same goes wherever you learn poli sci/history/anthropology/etc, since each part of the world will have their own interpretation of what's "right."
One might also argue that the reason that "the countries that had been most thoroughly colonized... were doing the best in the modern world" is that the "modern world" has largely been shaped by Western influence. One country may have been able to build on infrastructure developed under colonialism while the development of another may have been throttled (both phenomena perhaps being direct or indirect consequences of foreign intervention), with the former being more prepared for the "modern world" after attaining independence. It is not so much that one society/culture is better than another, but the problem of one system suddenly having to coexist inside another more overwhelming one.
No civilization is without conflict. But I would argue that colonization and the centuries-long chain of events it set off certainly did not help existing problems and a lot of groups. You're right that my post vastly oversimplifies things and almost comes across as a "noble savage" trope, but then again, this is letsrun, which is not the right format to discuss nuanced issues. :)