ex-runner wrote:
I still think Amos is more likely to break the WR than Brazier.
Amos last season, before he got injured, showed exactly the kind of balls Kipketer showed. He went out way too fast but still held it together for a 1:42.
In the 800 you need the confidence and lack of fear to go out fast and see what happens.
Sometimes, on a particular day, you will hold on to a decent pace after a fast first lap and run a crazy time.
It is not hard for me to imagine Amos going out in 49.0, splitting 1:14 at 600 and then holding on for a sub 27 to break 1:41.
If he didn't pull his hamstring in London and need a couple of weeks off we might have seen it last year.
I really agree with you here on the mindset. Really the key to 800m WR, as it was with Kipketer, is really committing to the 3rd 200m after getting as close as you can to the red line in the first 400m. Whoever does this needs to be 1.14.2 at 600m so figure your math from here.
It's interesting because I don't think Amos is quite as gifted at this point in his career as Brazier, but you make a good point that we know for a fact that Amos is prepared to lay it out there and we don't know this yet about Brazier who 1) hasn't even tested running low 49 through the bell and 2) hasn't committed to hammering the 3rd 200 after doing so.
Without the mindset to break the WR the physical ability means nothing and not every 800m runner just has "it". The odds are Brazier is going to have to try some insane splits like 48.9, 1.14.XX and then explode in a blaze of glory (unless he magically get's it right first time which would be incredible) - and how he mentally deals with that will be the essence of his potential.
Where perhaps we can agree to disagree is Amos's ability now. I would be stunned if he has another run in him close to the WR, even under 1.42 again. 1) even the greats only have a limited number of efforts at that level in them. Of the 5 athletes ever that broken 1.42, Rudisha did it 7 times, Kipketer 4, Coe and Cruz did it once and Amos twice. When you look at that list Amos is the least decorated of them all and the least talented (obviously we are talking of some all-time elite talents in the history of the sport though), so he's probably tapping his limits having run sub 1.42 twice. He just doesn't have the mechanics to support a low 1.41 race because his form is still atrocious under intense stress - especially compared to Rudisha and Kipketer who are two of the greatest movers in the history of running.
On the topic of running form it's interesting to note how crucial this is to the 800m at a sub 1.42 level. Kipketer to me is the greatest mover of all time and I know many pro's who saw him up close and personal agree with that - even in the era of El G. Rudisha a different type of runner more in the Juantorena mold of long, powerful and sustained striding and Coe of course had the moniker of "poetry in motion". Cruz similar to Rudisha with a massive stride that was a bit ungainly but sustainable under pressure. It is interesting that the two best guys right now, Brazier and Amos aren't really on that level. I don't know where I sit with Brazier tbh - maybe it's the hunched shoulders and overly bouncy gait that make him appear choppy? As I mentioned earlier I am still stunned and perplexed by how fast Amos has actually run because he is so awful in the last 120m. I mean I have my thoughts about athletes who can overcome and fight cr@ppy form in latter stages of races and still run incredibly fast (example Rashid Ramzi) but that's a different topic I guess.
Back to Brazier - what do I think he will run then? Well he has the physical ability to run very fast - the mental mindset I have no idea. So let's make it simple - if he has the mental aspect he can run 1.41.2, 1.41.3 - if not I think he can maybe take another 3/10ths off his current level and run 1.42.0