Bradley Manning... hero or traitor?

Face a trial for treason and then face the consequences.

If Assange's and Manning's goals are met, there will be no laws. Anarchists are the enemies of civilization. You must take into account their motivations, which at their heart are truly evil. A "Doomsday Leak" merely proves the point. It's like the cornered serial killer offing himself to deny civilization its pound of flesh. Never really considering anyone but themselves.

skwilli wrote:

If Assange's and Manning's goals are met, there will be no laws. Anarchists are the enemies of civilization. You must take into account their motivations, which at their heart are truly evil. A "Doomsday Leak" merely proves the point. It's like the cornered serial killer offing himself to deny civilization its pound of flesh. Never really considering anyone but themselves.

.

The people being ruled getting informed about what their rulers are up to is a bad thing?

Sometimes, I suppose. Not always. Irrelevant anyway. Assange is an avowed Anarchist. Anarchy is the enemy of EVERY ruling class, with secrets or without. What would one do with all the information in the World? Interesting concept. Separating the wheat from the chaff might prove to be monumental. I know Manning couldn't handle it correctly, but maybe you can.

Manning is innocent until proven guilty. He's not Palestinian and we're not Israel afterall. The US Govt lies and Obama lies. Have charges been filed yet ? We'll have to read the charges and have a jury trial, if it goes that far.

[quote]craigmac4h wrote:

Doesn't matter what people think about the information that was released. What matters is that Bradley was legally obligated by the Army not to release confidential information. He illegally obtained classified information and distributed it.

Horsesh&t. Immoral laws need to be challenged. Thuis is all about power --- those who want it want to keep it and expand it by staying in the shadows. They want no light shed.

Nobody has proven anything. Has he been charged ? In any case only in the US is Nazi-Zion considered acceptable behavior. The rest of the world condemns US and Nazi-Zion religious apartheid, and mass genocide of Muslims.

Nobody has proven anything. Has he been charged ? In any case only in the US is Nazi-Zion considered acceptable behavior. The rest of the world condemns US and Nazi-Zion religious apartheid, and mass genocide of Muslims.

This is Zion America. The govt can label any US citizen they wish a terrorist and hold him forever without charges or a right to face his accusers.